ST101 The Birth of Swamp Thing

The Lurker in Tunnel 13: Swamp Thing #8 and cosmic horror

A Lovecraftian entity in a DC comic. What cosmic horror asks of a monster who is also a man.

About 75 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

Swamp Thing #8, "The Lurker in Tunnel 13", introduces an entity called M'nagalah, a name built in the manner of H. P. Lovecraft's unpronounceable gods[1]. Where the earlier issues borrowed from the Gothic tradition of the ruined body and the persecuted outcast, this one reaches for a newer and colder kind of horror: the cosmic, in which the universe is indifferent, ancient and hungry, and the human scale barely registers.

What you are studying

One issue, and one question: what happens when a monster who is defined by his lost humanity meets a horror that treats humanity as irrelevant?

Learning objectives

  • Distinguish Gothic horror from cosmic horror by their assumptions.
  • Analyse how a comic represents the unrepresentable.
  • Consider what a cosmic threat does to a sympathetic monster.

Historical context

Lovecraft's stories, published in pulp magazines in the 1920s and 1930s, imagine gods older than the earth and a cosmos that does not care about us; "The Colour Out of Space" (Amazing Stories, September 1927) is the one most often cited as his finest, and it is a rural horror about something that falls into a farm and poisons the land. Later modules return to that story because it is also, plainly, an ecological horror. Here, notice that the horror tradition Wein reaches for has changed: the moors and witches of Week 3 were the Gothic's past; the cosmic is the twentieth century's addition.

Key concepts

Cosmic horror

Gothic horror is about transgression and return: something was done and it comes back. Cosmic horror is about scale and indifference: something was always there and never noticed us. The emotional keys are different, dread rather than guilt, awe rather than fear. Ask which key the issue plays in, and whether the creature's own story, which is Gothic, survives contact.

Representing the unrepresentable

Lovecraft's monsters are famously hard to draw because the prose insists they cannot be described. A comic has to show something. Watch how Wrightson handles it: how much of M'nagalah do you see, how soon, and from what angle? What does he hide?

The monster among monsters

When Swamp Thing meets a greater horror he is, briefly, the human in the room. Notice how the issue positions him: victim, opponent, or witness. This will matter in Year Two, when the character's relationship to the non-human becomes the whole subject.

Questions to think about while reading

  • Where is the tunnel, and why underground? What does the setting do to the light?
  • Who else is in the issue, and what is their function?
  • Does the issue end with the threat destroyed, contained, or merely left?

Things to notice

  • Wrightson's handling of mass without outline: the places where a shape is suggested by black alone.
  • Sound. Horror comics letter noise. Look for onomatopoeia and its absence.
  • The creature's own body, drawn against something stranger than itself.

Reflection questions

  • Were you more frightened by M'nagalah or by Arcane? What does the answer tell you about what frightens you?
  • Does cosmic horror suit a character who wants to be human again?

Homework and tasks

Write a short comparison of two frightening panels, one from this issue and one from #2 or #3: what each shows, what each hides, and how differently the fear works.

Next lesson

Next week the Wrightson era ends with issues #9 and #10, and you step back to look at the whole family of swamp monsters the character was born into.

References

  1. Len Wein (writer), Bernie Wrightson (artist). Swamp Thing #8: "The Lurker in Tunnel 13". Swamp Thing (1972 series), #8. DC Comics, 1974. Source requires verification

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.