ST101 The Birth of Swamp Thing

The swamp monster family tree: the Heap, "It" and Man-Thing

Swamp Thing was not the first thing to rise from a swamp. What the tradition explains.

About 120 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

Comics' first swamp monster was the Heap, who appeared in Hillman's Air Fighters Comics #3 (cover-dated December 1942), created by writer Harry Stein and artist Mort Leav[1]. Behind the Heap stands Theodore Sturgeon's 1940 short story "It", about a thing that assembles itself from the muck of a wood[2]. And beside Swamp Thing, almost to the month, stands Marvel's Man-Thing, who first appeared in Savage Tales #1 (May 1971) in a story scripted by Gerry Conway and drawn by Gray Morrow, from a character conceived by Roy Thomas and Stan Lee[3].

This lesson asks the historian's question the course has been circling: why 1971? And the critic's question that goes with it: what does it change to know that a character belongs to a type?

What you are studying

A type, the swamp monster, across three decades and three publishers, with Swamp Thing as one instance of it.

Learning objectives

  • Place a character in a tradition and account for the tradition's shape.
  • Compare texts across media (prose, Golden Age comics, 1970s comics).
  • Use the idea of the cultural body to explain why a type recurs.

Historical context

Sturgeon's story was published in the pulp magazine Unknown in August 1940 and collected in Without Sorcery in 1948[2]. The Heap began as a Second World War aviation comic's monster and outlived the war[1]. In 1971 the Comics Code had just been revised (in January) to allow the classic monsters of literature back into code-approved comics, and both DC and Marvel were expanding their horror lines; Man-Thing appeared in a black-and-white magazine that did not carry the Code at all, and Swamp Thing in a Code-approved anthology[3][4]. Module ST103 tells that history properly. For now: the swamp monster came back when the rules changed.

Key concepts

Type and instance

A type is a recurring figure with a stable set of features: here, a person who dies in wet ground and returns as vegetation, mute or nearly so, monstrous in form and pitiable in condition. An instance is one version. Criticism moves between the two: what does Swamp Thing share with the type, and what is only his?

Parallel creation

Two swamp creatures in one month is not plagiarism; it is a symptom. Cohen's argument that the monster's body is made of its culture's fears[5] predicts exactly this: when a culture has a fear, more than one artist will give it a body. Ask what fear, in 1971, had a swamp's shape. The Vietnam war? Pollution? The end of the sixties? Do not settle on an answer too quickly; the comics themselves are the evidence.

Reading across media

Sturgeon's story has no pictures; the Heap's are crude by later standards; Morrow's Man-Thing is drawn in a slick, painterly style very unlike Wrightson's. Comparing across media means asking what each medium can and cannot do with the same idea. What can prose do with a thing that has no face? What can a picture do?

Questions to think about while reading

  • In "It", who is the point-of-view character, and how does that choice shape your feeling for the creature?
  • What does the Heap want? Does the Heap want anything?
  • Man-Thing's touch burns those who feel fear. Swamp Thing has no such rule. What does each rule do to the stories that can be told?

Things to notice

  • The origins. Four characters, four deaths in wet ground. Line them up and compare what is kept.
  • The body. Vegetation, mud, moss: how does each version make a body out of the ground, and how does each artist draw decay?
  • Speech. Who can talk, and what does it cost the story when the monster cannot?

Reflection questions

  • Does knowing the type make Swamp Thing seem less original to you, or more interesting? Can it be both?
  • What would you say the swamp represents, across all four? Try one sentence.

Homework and tasks

Write the first draft of an argument, about four hundred words, answering: what kind of monster is Swamp Thing? Use the type to define your terms and at least two of the ten Wein and Wrightson issues as evidence. This draft feeds directly into Assignment 2.

Next lesson

This is the last lesson of the module. The two assignments are open from the module page. When both are marked and reflected on, ST102 Gothic Monsters begins, and it starts with Frankenstein.

References

  1. Harry Stein (writer), Mort Leav (artist). Air Fighters Comics #3 (first appearance of the Heap). Air Fighters Comics, #3. Hillman Periodicals, December 1942.
  2. Theodore Sturgeon. "It". Unknown. August 1940.
  3. Gerry Conway (script), Gray Morrow (art); character conceived by Roy Thomas and Stan Lee. Savage Tales #1 (first appearance of Man-Thing). Savage Tales, #1. Marvel Comics, May 1971.
  4. Len Wein (writer), Bernie Wrightson (artist). House of Secrets #92. House of Secrets, #92. DC Comics, July 1971.
  5. Jeffrey Jerome Cohen. "Monster Culture (Seven Theses)". Monster Theory: Reading Culture, ed. Jeffrey Jerome Cohen. University of Minnesota Press, 1996. Link

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.