ST105 Nature, Body & Transformation

Ecology without nature

Morton's argument that "nature" is an idea we made, and what it changes to drop it.

About 150 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

It seems obvious what happened to Alec Holland: he became part of nature. Timothy Morton's Ecology without Nature (2007) argues that the word doing the work in that sentence is the problem[1]. "Nature", Morton says, is an idea made largely by Romantic writing: something over there, pure, apart from us, to be admired from a distance. As long as we think of nature that way we cannot think ecologically, because ecology is the recognition that there is no over there.

This week is philosophy, and it is the hinge of the module. If Morton is right, then a character who "becomes nature" is either a Romantic fantasy or something stranger, and the difference is exactly what Year Two is about.

What you are studying

A philosophical argument about a word, and the exercise of testing an argument against texts you know.

Learning objectives

  • Summarise Morton's critique of the idea of nature.
  • Identify Romantic and post-Romantic constructions of nature in a text.
  • Apply the critique to Swamp Thing and to Lovecraft.

Key concepts

Nature as aesthetic

Morton's central move is to treat nature as an aesthetic effect produced by writing: the description that makes a landscape feel present and separate, which he calls ecomimesis[1]. Watch for it in Wein's captions about the swamp, and ask whether the writing makes the swamp a place apart or a place the reader is in.

The blasted heath again

Lovecraft's story from ST102 is a good test[2]. The colour is not nature and not culture; it comes from outside both. Ask whether Morton's argument helps with a horror that treats the ground itself as neither ours nor other.

Ecology without a swamp?

If nature is an idea, what is the swamp? Morton would say it is a set of relations, not a place apart. Try re-describing Swamp Thing's origin without the word nature and see what is left.

Questions to think about while reading

  • What are Morton's examples, and how many of them are Romantic poets?
  • What does he propose instead of nature? Is it usable?
  • Where in the Wein issues does the narration make the swamp beautiful, and to whom?

Things to notice

  • Morton's prose. It is deliberately playful and difficult. Decide whether that serves the argument.
  • The date. 2007 is before the Anthropocene became a common word. Does the argument age?
  • Your own resistance. Note the sentences you wanted to argue with; they are where your essay is.

Reflection questions

  • Do you believe in nature? What would you have to give up to stop?
  • Is Swamp Thing an ecological character or a Romantic one? Could he be both?

Homework and tasks

Write three hundred words re-describing Swamp Thing's origin in Swamp Thing #1 without using the word nature or any synonym, then a paragraph on what the constraint revealed.

Next lesson

Next week: trans-corporeality, and a contemporary swamp story in which the border between body and place dissolves for good.

References

  1. Timothy Morton. Ecology without Nature: Rethinking Environmental Aesthetics. Harvard University Press, 2007.
  2. H. P. Lovecraft. "The Colour Out of Space". Amazing Stories. September 1927. Link

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.