ST105 Nature, Body & Transformation
The swamp as body
Bringing four frameworks to one creature, and stating what he is before Moore changes the answer.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required Swamp Thing #1: "Dark Genesis" Len Wein (writer), Bernie Wrightson (artist) the whole issue
One last time this year.
-
Required Swamp Thing #2: "The Man Who Wanted Forever" Len Wein (writer), Bernie Wrightson (artist) the whole issue
-
Required Swamp Thing #3: "The Patchwork Man" Len Wein (writer), Bernie Wrightson (artist) the whole issue
-
Optional Savage Tales #1 (first appearance of Man-Thing) Gerry Conway (script), Gray Morrow (art); character conceived by Roy Thomas and Stan Lee the Man-Thing story
For contrast: Marvel's answer to the same question.
Introduction
Four frameworks. Bakhtin's grotesque, Kristeva's abject, Morton's critique of nature, Alaimo's trans-corporeality. Each describes a different aspect of the same body, and each fails to describe another. This lesson brings them together on the three issues that made the character and asks you to say, in terms a philosopher would accept, what Swamp Thing is.
The answer matters because Year Two begins with a story that changes it. Alan Moore's "The Anatomy Lesson" will tell you that everything you thought about this body was wrong. To feel the force of that, you need to have decided what you thought.
Learning objectives
- Compare four frameworks on their treatment of one body.
- Identify the questions each framework cannot answer.
- State a position on what Swamp Thing's body is, with evidence, before Year Two.
Key concepts
Frameworks as lenses
A lens shows some things and hides others. Bakhtin shows the body as process and hides the fear; Kristeva shows the fear and hides the joy; Morton questions the word nature and says little about bodies; Alaimo joins body and place but is not interested in monsters. Draw a grid: four frameworks against four questions (what is the body made of, where are its edges, what does it want, what does it mean), and fill it in.
Man-Thing as control
Marvel's creature is the same premise with different answers: he cannot think, he burns those who fear him, he is drawn as slime rather than vegetation[1]. A control case lets you see which of Swamp Thing's features are choices. Use it.
The question for Year Two
What does the creature want? In Wein and Wrightson it wants to be Alec Holland again. Moore will ask whether there was ever an Alec Holland to go back to. Write down, now, what you think the character's desire is, and what you think it should be.
Questions to think about while reading
- Which of the four frameworks best explains why the creature refuses Arcane?
- Which explains Wrightson's art best?
- Which would Wein have recognised, and which would have baffled him?
Things to notice
- Your definition from the start of the lesson. Has it survived the grid?
- The word "thing" in the character's name. None of the four frameworks quite deals with it.
- What Man-Thing lacks that Swamp Thing has, and whether it is the lack that makes Marvel's creature purer horror.
Reflection questions
- Which framework will you drop for Assignment 2, and why?
- What have you learned about your own body from a year of reading about this one?
Homework and tasks
Draft the introduction to Assignment 2: the two frameworks you will use, the body you will read, and the claim you expect to make.
Next lesson
This is the last lesson of ST105. Both assignments are open on the module page. ST106, Foundations of Horror Research, completes Year One by turning everything you have practised into method.
References
- Gerry Conway (script), Gray Morrow (art); character conceived by Roy Thomas and Stan Lee. Savage Tales #1 (first appearance of Man-Thing). Savage Tales, #1. Marvel Comics, May 1971.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.