ST201 The Anatomy Lesson and Personal Identity
Who is Swamp Thing now?
Setting your ST105 definition against Moore's, with the philosophy in hand.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required The Saga of the Swamp Thing #21: "The Anatomy Lesson" Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette (pencils), John Totleben (inks), Tatjana Wood (colours), John Costanza (letters) the whole issue
One more time, with everything you now know.
-
Recommended Alan Moore and the Gothic Tradition Matthew J. A. Green (editor) one chapter on Swamp Thing
For a second scholarly voice beside Di Liddo.
Introduction
At the end of ST105 you wrote a three-sentence definition of Swamp Thing's body. Moore has spent eight issues taking that definition apart. This last lesson puts the two side by side and asks you to write a third, with Locke and Parfit as referees and with the comics scholarship you have now read as the conversation you are entering.
Learning objectives
- State a defended position on what the creature is after #21.
- Use philosophical and critical sources as tools in a single argument.
- Prepare Assignment 2.
Key concepts
Three definitions
Wein's (a man transformed), Moore's (a plant that thinks it is a man), and yours. The third must be able to say why the first was wrong and what the second leaves out. The Green collection's chapters offer several candidates for what Moore's leaves out; read one and see whether you agree[1].
Philosophy as tool
An essay that summarises Parfit and then summarises the comic has two halves and no argument. The argument is in the application: this thought experiment, this page, this consequence. Practise the sentence "On Parfit's account, the page where ... shows that ...".
The scholarly conversation
Di Liddo and the Green collection are what others have said. Your Assignment 2 says what you think, in response. Use the they-say moves from ST106.
Questions to think about while reading
- Does the creature, by the end of #27, know what he is? Does he accept it?
- What does the Green add to the identity question that philosophy of mind does not consider?
- Where do Di Liddo and the Green collection disagree about what Moore did?
Things to notice
- Your own change of mind across six weeks. Track it; it is evidence too.
- The word "person". Which of the three definitions uses it, and should any?
- What Year Two's next module, on love and bodies, will need from the definition you write now.
Reflection questions
- If you were the creature, which definition would you want to be true?
- Has the philosophy made the comic better, or only more explicable?
Homework and tasks
Draft the introduction and plan of Assignment 2: your question, your four sources, your claim, and the page of the comic on which the argument turns.
Next lesson
This is the last lesson of ST201. Both assignments are open on the module page. ST202 follows: love, sex, bodies and the nonhuman, from "The Burial" to "Rite of Spring".
References
- Matthew J. A. Green (editor). Alan Moore and the Gothic Tradition. Manchester University Press, 2013.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.