ST202 Love, Sex, Bodies and the Nonhuman
What the run does to love
From burial to rite: the arc as an argument about loving what is not like you.
Reading for this lesson
-
Recommended Alan Moore and the Gothic Tradition Matthew J. A. Green (editor) one chapter on Swamp Thing
For the scholarly conversation.
-
Recommended Alan Moore: Comics as Performance, Fiction as Scalpel Annalisa Di Liddo the chapter on Swamp Thing
-
Optional Rabelais and His World Mikhail Bakhtin, translated by Helene Iswolsky the chapter on the grotesque body
Re-read with the love scene in mind: the open body, now in joy.
-
Optional Powers of Horror: An Essay on Abjection Julia Kristeva, translated by Leon S. Roudiez the opening chapter
The abject, now embraced.
Introduction
Seven issues and an annual, from a burial to a rite. Read in order they make an argument: that a creature who has given up being human can love, be loved, and be loved as what he is. The argument passes through violation (#29), death (#31), Hell (Annual #2), gentleness (#32), tradition (#33) and vision (#34). This last lesson asks whether the argument works, using the theory from Year One and the criticism you have now read.
Learning objectives
- Read a sequence of issues as a structured argument.
- Bring Year One's body theory to bear on intimacy.
- Engage with published criticism to form and defend a judgement.
Key concepts
The arc as argument
Every step of the sequence does something to the possibility of love: takes it away, corrupts it, retrieves it, tests it, achieves it. Write the sequence as a syllogism and see whether it is valid. Then see whether the comic is more interesting than the syllogism.
The body, joyful
Bakhtin's grotesque body was carnival, joyful, open[1]; ST105 asked where the joy went in horror. "Rite of Spring" is where it comes back. Kristeva's abject was what the self expels[2]; Abby eats it. The love scene reverses Year One's horror term by term. Say so with evidence.
The critics
Di Liddo reads the run as a dissection of the tradition[3]; the Green collection reads it as Gothic[4]. Neither may be primarily about love. Ask what a reading centred on love would add, and whether you are the person to write it.
Questions to think about while reading
- Which issue in the sequence is the argument's weakest link?
- Does Abby have an inner life in these issues, or is she a function of the creature's?
- What does the run gain by making its love story a horror story first?
Things to notice
- Your own paragraph from the start of the lesson. Has the lesson changed it?
- The word "unnatural". It will matter in ST206. Note where it first appears.
- Bissette and Totleben's covers across the sequence, as a sequence.
Reflection questions
- Is loving the nonhuman a fantasy, an ethic, or both?
- What has this module taught you about how you read love in fiction?
Homework and tasks
Draft the introduction and plan of Assignment 2: your position on whether the run earns its love story, your four sources, and the page on which the argument turns.
Next lesson
This is the last lesson of ST202. Both assignments are open on the module page. ST203, American Gothic, follows: Constantine arrives, and the comic goes on the road.
References
- Mikhail Bakhtin, translated by Helene Iswolsky. Rabelais and His World. Indiana University Press, 1984 (Russian original 1965).
- Julia Kristeva, translated by Leon S. Roudiez. Powers of Horror: An Essay on Abjection. Columbia University Press, 1982 (French original 1980).
- Annalisa Di Liddo. Alan Moore: Comics as Performance, Fiction as Scalpel. University Press of Mississippi, 2009.
- Matthew J. A. Green (editor). Alan Moore and the Gothic Tradition. Manchester University Press, 2013.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.