ST206 Cosmic Swamp Thing and Moore's Legacy
Crimes against nature: #51 to #53
Abby prosecuted for loving a plant, a city overgrown, and the superhero world's answer to the creature.
Reading for this lesson
-
Gotham, Batman, the device.
Introduction
After #50 the run comes home and finds the law waiting. Abby is charged with crimes against nature for her relationship with the creature; she flees to Gotham City and is arrested by the vice squad[1][2]. The creature follows and does what he did not do to Woodrue's oxygen or the Darkness: he takes a city. Gotham is overgrown, street by street, until Abby is released. Batman appears. And Lex Luthor's experts, consulted by the government, design a device to scramble the frequency the creature uses to grow himself a body. It works. He dies[3].
The storyline is the run's most political and its most superheroic at once. The word "unnatural", which you were told to watch for in ST202, is here made into a statute. This lesson reads the three issues as a story about law, love and what a society will do to something it cannot classify, and as Moore's confrontation with the DC universe he had mostly kept at a distance.
Learning objectives
- Analyse the Gotham storyline as a story about law and the nonhuman.
- Read the creature's occupation of Gotham as a political act and a formal set-piece.
- Assess Moore's use of Batman and Luthor as the shared universe's answer to what he had built.
Key concepts
The statute
"Crimes against nature" is a real legal category with a history of being used against people whose love the state disliked. The storyline knows this. Ask what the choice of charge claims, and who the story wants you to think of when Abby is arrested.
The green city
The creature's overgrowing of Gotham is the Green as protest. Read the pages of the city changing: what grows, where, how fast, and what the people do. Then ask whether it is a threat or a demonstration, and whether the story can tell the difference.
The device
Luthor's scrambler is science's answer to a mystery, and it works. Ask what it means that the creature, who survived the Darkness, is killed by a piece of engineering, and what that says about the run's view of the superhero world.
Questions to think about while reading
- What does Batman say to the authorities, and what does the story think of him?
- How does Abby respond to her arrest? Does she defend herself?
- How is the creature's death drawn, and what does the last page of #53 promise?
Things to notice
- Gotham as a Gothic city. The name says so. Compare with the American Gothic towns.
- Newspapers and television inside the story. The public story of the case.
- Totleben's vegetation on architecture. Where his art is most at home.
Reflection questions
- Is the creature's occupation of Gotham justified? Would you have said so in 1986?
- What would this storyline look like if published today?
Homework and tasks
Write three hundred words on the Gotham storyline as a story about law: the statute, the protest, the device, and what the sequence says about how a society handles what it cannot classify.
Next lesson
Next week: the funeral and the blue planet.
References
- Alan Moore (writer). Swamp Thing #51: "Home Free". Swamp Thing, #51. DC Comics, August 1986. Source requires verification
- Alan Moore (writer). Swamp Thing #52. Swamp Thing, #52. DC Comics, 1986. Source requires verification
- Alan Moore (writer), John Totleben (art). Swamp Thing #53. Swamp Thing, #53. DC Comics, 1986.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.