ST206 Cosmic Swamp Thing and Moore's Legacy
Rann and Technis: #57 to #60
Adam Strange's planet at war, an issue without the creature, and the machine world Totleben built by hand.
Reading for this lesson
-
Recommended Swamp Thing #59: "Reunion" Stephen Bissette (script), from a plot by Alan Moore the whole issue
Bissette's script; the creature absent.
-
Required Swamp Thing #60: "Loving the Alien" Alan Moore (writer), John Totleben (art) the whole issue, twice
A candidate for Assignment 1.
-
For reading #60's collage.
Introduction
The exile continues. On Rann, the world of DC's science-fiction hero Adam Strange, the creature finds a planet whose people are at war and whose ecology is failing, and he is asked to do for it what he does for swamps[1]. Issue #59, scripted by Stephen Bissette, leaves him out entirely and spends its pages on Arcane's punishment in Hell[2]. And in "Loving the Alien" (May 1987) he lands on Technis, a living machine, and John Totleben makes the issue from metal scraps, pasted photographs of machinery and a sculpted model of the creature[3].
The three stops test three limits: what the creature can do for a world that is not his; what the comic can do without him; and what the page can do when it stops being drawn. This lesson reads each, with #60 as the module's formal climax.
Learning objectives
- Analyse the Rann story as an ecological fable in a science-fiction setting.
- Assess what an issue without its protagonist reveals about the series.
- Read #60's collage with the ST104 vocabulary and McCloud's picture plane.
Key concepts
The elemental abroad
On Rann the creature is asked to be a planet's gardener. Ask what the story says about ecological repair as a service, and whether the creature's Green is exportable. Compare with #61's J586, which has its own.
The absent centre
#59 is a Swamp Thing comic without Swamp Thing, scripted by the artist who drew him. Ask what the series is when he is gone, and what Bissette's script does that Moore's would not.
The page as object
#60 is made of things, not drawings. McCloud's picture plane, the place where the image stops representing and becomes itself[4], is the tool. Describe what the collage does to the creature's body, to the reader's eye, and to the idea of a machine world, and ask whether the form is the meaning.
Questions to think about while reading
- What is wrong with Rann, and what does the creature do about it?
- In #59, how is Hell drawn, and is it the same Hell as Annual #2?
- In #60, where is the line between photograph and drawing, and does it matter?
Things to notice
- Adam Strange. A 1950s science-fiction hero in a 1980s horror comic. What each does to the other.
- Bissette's captions in #59. A different voice.
- Totleben's model of the creature in #60. A sculpture photographed. The character has become an object.
Reflection questions
- Is #60 a comic?
- What does the exile sequence say about what the creature is, now that he can be anywhere?
Homework and tasks
Write three hundred and fifty words reading #60 with McCloud: what the collage does to representation, and whether the form carries the issue's meaning or replaces it.
Next lesson
Next week: homecoming. #63 and #64, and the goodbye.
References
- Alan Moore (writer). Swamp Thing #57 and #58. Swamp Thing, #57 to 58. DC Comics, 1987.
- Stephen Bissette (script), from a plot by Alan Moore. Swamp Thing #59: "Reunion". Swamp Thing, #59. DC Comics, April 1987.
- Alan Moore (writer), John Totleben (art). Swamp Thing #60: "Loving the Alien". Swamp Thing, #60. DC Comics, May 1987.
- Scott McCloud. Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art. Kitchen Sink Press (later HarperCollins), 1993.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.