ST206 Cosmic Swamp Thing and Moore's Legacy
Writing for Comics: Moore's craft in his own words
The 1985 essay, written mid-run, read against the pages it was written beside.
Reading for this lesson
-
The 1985 essay and the 2003 afterword.
-
Optional The Saga of the Swamp Thing #21: "The Anatomy Lesson" Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette (pencils), John Totleben (inks), Tatjana Wood (colours), John Costanza (letters) the whole issue
Re-read from ST201 as the essay's best example.
Introduction
Between August 1985 and February 1986, while writing American Gothic, Moore published a four-part essay on how to write comics in the British fan magazine Fantasy Advertiser. Avatar Press collected it in 2003 with a new afterword in which Moore, older and a magician, reconsiders his younger self[1]. The essay is the run's theory, contemporary with its practice: how to think about an idea, a structure, a page, a panel, a reader's mind.
This lesson reads the essay as a tool for reading the run. Every claim Moore makes about craft can be tested against a page you have already read closely. The afterword is a second text: a writer disagreeing with himself about what comics are for.
Learning objectives
- Summarise Moore's 1985 account of comics craft accurately.
- Test its claims against specific pages of the run.
- Analyse the 2003 afterword as a revision of the method.
Key concepts
Idea, structure, page
The essay moves from the idea to its structure to the page and the panel. Take one lesson's worth of pages you know well (#21, #34, #56) and read them with the essay's terms. Where the pages do what the essay says, and where they do something the essay does not describe, is the reading.
The reader's mind
Moore's recurring subject is what happens in the reader: pacing, transition, the control of time. Connect this to ST104's McCloud and to ST205's magic. If craft is the control of a reader's experience, the essay is already about changing consciousness.
The afterword
The 2003 Moore thinks the 1985 Moore was too concerned with technique. Ask whether he is right, using the run as evidence: is the run's power in its craft, or in something the craft served?
Questions to think about while reading
- What does Moore say a comics idea should be, and does #21 have one?
- What does he say about the panel as a unit of time? Test it on #34.
- What does the afterword regret?
Things to notice
- The audience. The essay was written for fans in a small magazine. The tone.
- Examples. Which comics Moore cites, and whether Swamp Thing is among them.
- Dates. The essay overlaps #40 to #46. Which issues were on his desk?
Reflection questions
- Would you rather read a writer's theory before or after his work?
- Is the older Moore's disagreement with himself a correction or a loss?
Homework and tasks
Write three hundred words testing one claim from the 1985 essay against one page of the run, citing both, and ending with whether the page confirms, exceeds or contradicts the claim.
Next lesson
Last week: the legacy, and the essay on the run as a whole.
References
- Alan Moore. Alan Moore's Writing for Comics. Avatar Press, 2003 (essay first serialised in Fantasy Advertiser #92 to #95, August 1985 to February 1986).
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.