ST302 The Wider DC Horror Line: From Cain and Abel to Vertigo

After Vertigo, and the essay

Justice League Dark, Black Label, the end of the imprint, and the question of origins.

About 120 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

Justice League Dark #1 (September 2011) put Constantine, Zatanna, Deadman, Shade and Madame Xanadu in a team book in the superhero line[1]: the supernatural stock, which Moore had used for horror and Gaiman for myth, returned as a franchise. Vertigo itself was wound down at the end of the 2010s (find the date and the announcement; do not take it from memory), and DC Black Label became the prestige imprint that published Lemire's Green Hell and Veitch's completed 1989 story (ST301). The characters outlived the imprint.

This last lesson reads the afterlife and turns to the essay. The claim "Vertigo began with Moore's Swamp Thing" is made often. The module has given you the inheritance (Weeks 1 and 2), the generation (Weeks 3 and 4) and the imprint (Week 5). The essay asks you to say how true the claim is, and what kind of truth it would be.

What you are studying

The evaluation of an origin story.

Learning objectives

  • Analyse Justice League Dark #1 as the stock's return to the superhero line.
  • Assess the end of Vertigo and the rise of Black Label as evidence about what the imprint was.
  • Evaluate a causal claim in comics history.

Key concepts

Origin stories

Every institution tells one. "Vertigo began with Swamp Thing" flatters the run, the editor and the imprint. Ask who tells it, when, and what it leaves out: the anthology hosts, the 1971 Code revision, the direct market, the trade paperback, Sandman's sales.

Kinds of cause

Necessary, sufficient, contributing, symbolic. Decide which the run was. A first-class essay will say which and show why the others do not fit.

The franchise

Justice League Dark is what the stock became when horror was no longer the point. Ask whether the return to the superhero line is a betrayal of the inheritance or its natural state, and what Moore's cosmology looks like as a team.

Questions to think about while reading

  • Who assembles the team in Justice League Dark #1, and against what?
  • What does Milligan's Constantine owe to Delano's and to Moore's?
  • What did DC say when it ended Vertigo, and what did it say Black Label was for?

Things to notice

  • Your paragraph. Revise it.
  • The word "began". It hides a theory of causation. Choose yours.
  • Which sources in this module are publisher accounts, which creator accounts, which scholarship. The essay cites each as what it is.

Reflection questions

  • Does it matter where Vertigo began?
  • What would the history look like told from Berger's desk rather than Moore's script?

Homework and tasks

Draft the plan of Assignment 2: your answer, the kind of cause you claim, the evidence from each week, and the sources you have traced.

Next lesson

This is the last lesson of ST302. Both assignments are open. ST303 follows: Swamp Thing on screen.

References

  1. Peter Milligan (writer), Mikel Janín (art). Justice League Dark #1. Justice League Dark, #1. DC Comics, released 28 September 2011.

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.