ST303 Swamp Thing on Screen: Film, Television and Adaptation
The 2019 series
The first adaptation built on Moore, and the industrial story of its cancellation.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required Swamp Thing (DC Universe, 2019) Mark Verheiden and Gary Dauberman (showrunners), James Wan (executive producer); Crystal Reed (Abby Arcane), Andy Bean (Alec Holland), Derek Mears (Swamp Thing) the whole season, ten episodes
-
Required The Saga of the Swamp Thing #21: "The Anatomy Lesson" Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette (pencils), John Totleben (inks), Tatjana Wood (colours), John Costanza (letters) the whole issue
The source the series finally used.
-
How the cancellation was explained, and mis-explained.
Introduction
The 2019 Swamp Thing, made for the DC Universe streaming service with James Wan producing and Mark Verheiden and Gary Dauberman as showrunners, cast Crystal Reed as Abby Arcane, Andy Bean as Alec Holland and Derek Mears as the creature, set the story in Marais, Louisiana, and shot it in Wilmington, North Carolina[1]. It was the first adaptation to use Moore: the Green, the Rot, the question of what the creature is. Its episode order was cut from thirteen to ten during production, and it was cancelled after its first episode aired. The explanation that circulated, a North Carolina tax-rebate error, was disputed by the state and picked apart by the trade press[2].
This lesson reads the series as the adaptation the module has been waiting for, and its cancellation as a case study in how industrial explanations are made and unmade.
Learning objectives
- Analyse the series' use of Moore's run, scene by scene where possible.
- Assess what streaming afforded that broadcast and film had not.
- Evaluate competing explanations for the cancellation from documented sources.
Key concepts
Moore on screen
Find the Anatomy Lesson. It is in there, adapted. Compare the scene with #21[3]: what the series keeps, what it cannot do (the page's structure, the reveal's pacing), what it does instead. Then find the Green, and ask whether photography can show it.
Streaming
A ten-episode streaming season has no status quo to protect and no toys to sell. Ask what the format allowed the series to do with horror, and what it did with the freedom.
Explanations
The tax story was widely reported and, per the trade press, wrong or at least incomplete. Ask how it spread, who benefited from it, and what the documented sources actually support. This is the discipline of Assignment 2: industry claims must be traced.
Questions to think about while reading
- How does the series stage the transformation, and how long does it wait?
- What is Abby's role, and is she Moore's Abby?
- What does the Deadline article say was known, and by whom, about the rebate?
Things to notice
- Mears's creature. Practical, again, but with thirty-seven years of effects work behind it.
- The town. Marais as a Louisiana Gothic setting, compared with the American Gothic towns.
- The last episode. Cut from thirteen, it ends where it can.
Reflection questions
- Was this the adaptation the run deserved?
- Why do industrial explanations spread faster than corrections?
Homework and tasks
Draft Assignment 1: the 2019 series' Anatomy Lesson against #21, or any other adaptation against its source, as a Hutcheon adaptation.
Next lesson
Next week: the film that has not been made.
References
- Mark Verheiden and Gary Dauberman (showrunners), James Wan (executive producer); Crystal Reed (Abby Arcane), Andy Bean (Alec Holland), Derek Mears (Swamp Thing). Swamp Thing (DC Universe, 2019). 2019; ten episodes, reduced from a planned thirteen.
- "Swamp Thing" Cancellation Coverage Muddied by Tall Tales of Tax Snafu. Deadline. June 2019. Link
- Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette (pencils), John Totleben (inks), Tatjana Wood (colours), John Costanza (letters). The Saga of the Swamp Thing #21: "The Anatomy Lesson". The Saga of the Swamp Thing, #21. DC Comics, February 1984.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.