ST303 Swamp Thing on Screen: Film, Television and Adaptation
Why the screen resists
Five adaptations, one unmade film, and the question of whether the resistance is in the character, the comic, or the industry.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required A Theory of Adaptation Linda Hutcheon, with Siobhan O'Flynn (second edition) the conclusion
-
Recommended The Saga of the Swamp Thing #34: "Rite of Spring" Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette and John Totleben (art) the vision pages
The sequence no adaptation has attempted.
Introduction
A monster movie, a comedy, a syndicated series, a cartoon, a cancelled streaming season, an unmade film. The module has read each on Hutcheon's terms. The last lesson asks the question they add up to: why has a character this important to comics never worked on screen? Three answers are available and they are not exclusive. The character: a plant who thinks, whose best stories are interior. The comic: Moore's run is made of things the page does (the Anatomy Lesson's structure, the vision pages of #34, the collage of #60) that film cannot reproduce and has not found equivalents for. The industry: budgets, formats, tax rebates, slates, none of which care what the character is.
The essay asks you to weigh the three, with the evidence of six weeks and Hutcheon's theory, and to say which explanation is strongest and what an adaptation that overcame it would have to do.
Learning objectives
- Synthesise the screen history into an argument.
- Weigh textual, formal and industrial explanations against each other.
- Plan a research essay that combines close analysis with traced industry evidence.
Key concepts
The character
Is the creature unfilmable? Test the claim against the 2019 series, which came closest. Note what it could do and what it could not.
The comic
Take one sequence no adaptation has attempted (#34's vision pages are the obvious case[1]) and describe what a film would have to do. If you cannot describe it, that is evidence; if you can, that is evidence too.
The industry
Every adaptation's fate has a documented industrial story. Weigh them: how much of the resistance is money and format, and how much is the character?
Questions to think about while reading
- Which adaptation came closest, and by what standard?
- What does Hutcheon's conclusion say about why adaptations fail?
- What would you need to see in the first ten minutes of a Swamp Thing film to believe it understood the run?
Things to notice
- Your paragraph. Revise it.
- The word "worked". It hides a standard. Choose yours.
- Which sources are textual analysis, which theory, which industry evidence. The essay uses all three and labels each.
Reflection questions
- Is it a loss that the character has not worked on screen, or a protection?
- Has this module changed how you watch adaptations?
Homework and tasks
Draft the plan of Assignment 2: your explanation, the adaptations you will analyse, the sequence you will use as the formal test, the industry evidence you have traced, and Hutcheon's role.
Next lesson
This is the last lesson of ST303. Both assignments are open. ST304 follows: modern eco-horror and folk horror.
References
- Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette and John Totleben (art). The Saga of the Swamp Thing #34: "Rite of Spring". The Saga of the Swamp Thing, #34. DC Comics, March 1985.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.