ST101 The Birth of Swamp Thing

Origins, twice told: House of Secrets #92 and Swamp Thing #1

Wein and Wrightson rewrite their own story. What they keep tells you what matters.

About 90 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

When DC gave Wein and Wrightson a series, they did not continue the House of Secrets story. They started again. Swamp Thing #1, "Dark Genesis" (cover-dated October to November 1972), moves the story from the Victorian era to the present, renames the scientist Alec Holland, gives him a wife, Linda, a project, a bio-restorative formula, and a place, the Louisiana swamp, and has him killed by a bomb planted for a shadowy group called the Conclave[1].

A story told twice by the same people is a gift to a critic. Everything they changed was a choice, and everything they kept was a stronger one.

What you are studying

Two origin stories, sixteen months apart, from the same writer and artist. The first is an anthology short with a Victorian setting and a scientist named Olsen[2]. The second is a series opener with a contemporary setting, a scientist named Holland, a government agent named Matt Cable, and a conspiracy[1]. Both end with a body in the swamp and a creature climbing out of it.

Learning objectives

  • Compare two versions of a story and account for the differences as choices.
  • Identify what an origin story has to do that a standalone horror story does not.
  • Notice how a series opener plants threads for later issues.

Key concepts

The origin story

Superhero comics run on origins: the single event that explains the character and licenses everything after. A horror anthology story does not need one; it needs an ending. Moving Swamp Thing from one form to the other meant turning a twist into a beginning. Watch how "Dark Genesis" handles the moment the House of Secrets story ended on. Where the short story stops, the series has to keep going, and the question of what the creature wants becomes the engine.

The laboratory

The Gothic scientist whose experiment makes a monster is Mary Shelley's gift to the tradition, and Botting traces its afterlife through the nineteenth century into film[3]. Wein gives Holland a formula intended to make deserts bloom. Notice the difference between a scientist who transgresses and a scientist who is wronged. Which is Olsen? Which is Holland? What does the change do to how you feel about the creature?

Threads

A series opener seeds. Mr E and the Conclave, Matt Cable, Linda Holland: each is an obligation the comic takes on, a promise to return. Anthology stories make no promises. List every thread "Dark Genesis" leaves loose and guess which ones Wein will pull.

Questions to think about while reading

  • In each version, at what point does the reader know more than the scientist? Is the dramatic irony placed in the same spot?
  • How does the swamp look different in 1972? Is it drawn as a place or as a mood?
  • Who is the villain of #1? Is there one, in the way Ridge is the villain of the short?
  • What does the last page of #1 ask you to feel that the last page of the short did not?

Things to notice

  • Wrightson's creature has changed. Compare the two designs panel by panel: the face, the eyes, the way it stands.
  • The captions. Is the narration in the same voice? Does it stay outside the creature or move inside its head?
  • Page count. The series has twenty or so pages where the short had eight. Where does Wein spend the extra room?

Reflection questions

  • If you had only ever read #1, what would you assume about the short? If only the short, what would you assume about #1?
  • Which version is the better horror story? Which is the better beginning? Are those the same question?

Homework and tasks

Build a comparison table with at least eight rows (setting, scientist, cause of death, who is responsible, what the creature does first, how the story ends, narration, design of the creature). Then write one paragraph arguing which single change matters most.

Next lesson

Next week: Anton Arcane, the Un-Men and the Patchwork Man, and the question the series will ask for fifty years: what would you give to be human again?

References

  1. Len Wein (writer), Bernie Wrightson (artist). Swamp Thing #1: "Dark Genesis". Swamp Thing (1972 series), #1. DC Comics, October to November 1972. Link
  2. Len Wein (writer), Bernie Wrightson (artist). House of Secrets #92. House of Secrets, #92. DC Comics, July 1971.
  3. Fred Botting. Gothic. The New Critical Idiom. Routledge, 2014 (second edition; first edition 1996).

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.