ST101 The Birth of Swamp Thing

Arcane and the Un-Men: Swamp Thing #2

The villain arrives with an offer, and the series finds its central question.

About 75 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

Swamp Thing #2, "The Man Who Wanted Forever" (January 1973), introduces Anton Arcane and his Un-Men, reanimated and reassembled synthetic men who capture the creature and bring it to their maker[1]. Arcane's offer is the hinge of the issue and, it turns out, of the whole mythos: he can make Swamp Thing human again, but only if Arcane takes the monstrous body for himself[1].

What you are studying

A villain's first appearance, a horde of made monsters, and a bargain. The issue is structured around temptation, which makes it a good place to ask what the creature wants, because the story finally has to say.

Learning objectives

  • Analyse a villain as a mirror of the hero.
  • Apply Cohen's idea that the monster's body is a cultural body to a specific set of monsters.
  • Identify the ethical question a story is built around and trace how the plot answers it.

Key concepts

The double

Arcane wants what Swamp Thing has and Swamp Thing wants what Arcane has: a body that will last, a body that is human. Gothic fiction is full of doubles, figures who share a self between two bodies, and Botting shows how often the double is used to externalise a fear about identity[2]. Read Arcane as Swamp Thing's double and see what that explains.

Made monsters

Cohen's first thesis is that the monster's body is a cultural body: it is made of the fears and desires of its time[3]. The Un-Men are literally made. Ask what they are made of, in the story and in 1973: what anxieties about science, bodies and ownership do they carry?

Temptation plots

A temptation plot tests a character by offering what they most want at a price. The reader's job is to notice what the price reveals. Here, notice that the price is not paid by the creature. Whose body is on the table, and does the story treat that as a horror or a relief?

Questions to think about while reading

  • How does Wrightson draw Arcane's face compared with the creature's? Which is more monstrous on the page, and is that the same as which is more monstrous in the story?
  • Where does the offer happen in the issue? What has the story done to you before it is made?
  • What do the Un-Men want, if anything? Are they characters or scenery?

Things to notice

  • Interiors. This issue moves indoors, into Arcane's space. Watch how Wrightson lights it compared with the swamp.
  • The lettering of Arcane's speech. Does it differ from other characters'?
  • The final page. Does it resolve the offer or defer it?

Reflection questions

  • What would you have given to be human again? Does the story let you answer honestly?
  • Which of Cohen's seven theses fits Arcane best, and which fits the Un-Men?

Homework and tasks

Write a short character analysis of Arcane (about three hundred words) as a double of Swamp Thing. Use at least three panels as evidence, described precisely enough that a reader could find them.

Next lesson

Next: the Balkans, a castle, a daughter and the Patchwork Man, in the issue where the debt to Frankenstein comes due.

References

  1. Len Wein (writer), Bernie Wrightson (artist). Swamp Thing #2: "The Man Who Wanted Forever". Swamp Thing (1972 series), #2. DC Comics, January 1973.
  2. Fred Botting. Gothic. The New Critical Idiom. Routledge, 2014 (second edition; first edition 1996).
  3. Jeffrey Jerome Cohen. "Monster Culture (Seven Theses)". Monster Theory: Reading Culture, ed. Jeffrey Jerome Cohen. University of Minnesota Press, 1996. Link

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.