ST101 The Birth of Swamp Thing

The Patchwork Man: Swamp Thing #3 and the debt to Frankenstein

Abigail Arcane appears, and Wein and Wrightson pay Mary Shelley back in full.

About 75 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

Swamp Thing #3, "The Patchwork Man" (cover-dated February to March 1973), takes the creature to the Balkans, introduces Anton Arcane's daughter Abigail, and sets Swamp Thing against a stitched-together man[1]. Abby will become the most important person in the character's life across every later run. The Patchwork Man is a Frankenstein's creature by another name, and the issue is where the series says out loud what it has been implying since page one.

What you are studying

A single issue that does three jobs: it introduces a heroine, it stages a fight between two made monsters, and it sends the reader back to the novel the whole tradition starts with.

Learning objectives

  • Recognise an allusion and explain what it adds rather than just noting it.
  • Analyse a first appearance: what the story needs a new character to do.
  • Compare two monsters within one story.

Historical context

Mary Shelley's Frankenstein was published in 1818 and revised in 1831; the creature, assembled from parts and abandoned by his maker, is the pattern for every sympathetic made monster since, and Botting reads the novel as the point where Gothic horror turns from ghosts to science[2]. Wrightson knew the book deeply: after Swamp Thing he spent years on a pen-and-ink illustrated edition, published in 1983 with an introduction by Stephen King[3]. Read the Patchwork Man as an early draft of that obsession.

Key concepts

Allusion

An allusion is a reference to another text that asks the reader to bring that text's meaning with them. Noting "this is like Frankenstein" is the beginning of a thought, not the end. The analysis is in the difference: what does Wein's patchwork man have that Shelley's creature does not, and what has he lost?

The first appearance

When a character appears for the first time, the story reveals what it needs them for. Ask what Abby does in this issue that no existing character could do. Then ask what the issue assumes about her future.

Two monsters

Put the Patchwork Man and Swamp Thing in the same panel and describe the difference in how they are drawn: line, mass, face, eyes. Then ask which the story wants you to fear and which to pity, and whether the art agrees with the script.

Questions to think about while reading

  • What is the first thing you learn about Abby, and from whom?
  • Who made the Patchwork Man, and does the story let him speak?
  • Where does the fight happen, and what does the setting do to it?
  • Does the creature have a choice at the end of the issue? Did it in #2?

Things to notice

  • Wrightson's castles and interiors, and how they differ from the swamp pages.
  • The pacing of the reveal of the Patchwork Man. How many panels before you see him whole?
  • Abby's face. Wrightson draws her differently from everyone else in the issue. How?

Reflection questions

  • Did the Frankenstein connection make the story richer for you, or did it feel borrowed?
  • Which of the two monsters did you sympathise with more, and at what panel did that settle?

Homework and tasks

Write a paragraph of analysis (not summary) on the allusion to Frankenstein in this issue: what it borrows, what it changes, and what the change means.

Next lesson

Next week is a tour: three issues that each try on a different kind of horror, and a question about what the wandering monster is for.

References

  1. Len Wein (writer), Bernie Wrightson (artist). Swamp Thing #3: "The Patchwork Man". Swamp Thing (1972 series), #3. DC Comics, February to March 1973.
  2. Fred Botting. Gothic. The New Critical Idiom. Routledge, 2014 (second edition; first edition 1996).
  3. Mary Shelley (text), Bernie Wrightson (illustrations), introduction by Stephen King. Bernie Wrightson's Frankenstein. Marvel Comics (softcover) and Dodd, Mead & Co. (hardcover), 1983.

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.