ST103 History of Horror Comics

EC and the horror boom

Tales from the Crypt, the Vault, the Haunt, and the stories that used shock to say something.

About 120 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

Between the end of the Second World War and 1954, American comic books sold in numbers that no later period matched, and horror was one of the engines. EC Comics, under publisher William Gaines and editor Al Feldstein, produced Tales from the Crypt, The Vault of Horror and The Haunt of Fear: hosted anthologies of twist-ending stories drawn by the strongest artists in the business[1]. Wrightson grew up on them. The Swamp Thing story in House of Secrets #92 is an EC story in shape: eight pages, a host, a turn at the end.

EC also did something the panic that followed never mentioned. Qiana Whitted's study shows that the same publisher used the horror and science-fiction formats to attack racism, lynching and antisemitism in stories the staff called preachies, of which "Judgment Day!" is the most famous[2][3]. Horror was a way of saying things.

What you are studying

The EC house style as a set of choices (the host, the twist, the moral economy of punishment), and the argument that those choices were doing political work.

Learning objectives

  • Describe the EC horror story as a form with identifiable conventions.
  • Explain the preachies and Whitted's argument about them.
  • Connect the EC format to House of Secrets #92.

Historical context

Bradford Wright's Comic Book Nation gives the frame: comics as a mass medium for the young in the 1940s and 1950s, a publishing free-for-all with little oversight, and a product that adults mostly never read[4]. David Hajdu's The Ten-Cent Plague tells the same years as a story of people: the writers and artists in the New York shops, the campaigners who organised comic burnings, the retailers caught between[5]. Read the two together and you have the boom from above and from below.

Key concepts

The hosted anthology

A host is a narrator with a personality who introduces and closes each story. EC's Crypt-Keeper, Vault-Keeper and Old Witch licensed the gruesome by treating it as a joke shared with the reader. DC's Cain and Abel, in the late 1960s, are the direct descendants, and the Swamp Thing story is told under Abel's roof.

The twist and the moral economy

EC stories usually end with a reversal in which a wrongdoer is punished, often by the thing he did. The moral economy is exact: what you did comes back for you. Notice how the House of Secrets story keeps that economy, and how later Swamp Thing stories break it.

Shock as argument

Whitted's claim is that EC's shock aesthetics were not separable from its social protest: the same devices that made a reader gasp at a rotting corpse made a reader gasp at a lynching[2]. That is a claim about form doing political work, and it is the kind of claim this course wants you to be able to make and test.

Questions to think about while reading

  • In your two horror stories, who is punished and for what? Is the punishment proportionate?
  • How does the host frame each story: as warning, as joke, as both?
  • In "Judgment Day!", what does the final panel reveal and how does the reveal depend on the reader's assumptions?

Things to notice

  • Panel counts. EC pages are dense. Count and compare with a Wrightson page.
  • Captions. EC stories are heavily narrated. What tone does the narration take?
  • The art. Which artists drew your stories? Look them up on the Grand Comics Database and note who they were.

Reflection questions

  • Were the stories frightening, funny, or both? Would a twelve-year-old in 1952 have answered differently?
  • Does knowing about the preachies change your view of the horror titles?

Homework and tasks

Write two hundred words on one EC horror story as a form: host, set-up, turn, punishment. Then one paragraph on whether House of Secrets #92 follows the pattern.

Next lesson

Next week: the panic. Wertham's book, the Senate hearings, the Code, and the end of EC's horror line.

References

  1. Al Feldstein, William Gaines and the EC artists. Tales from the Crypt (EC, 1950 to 1955). Tales from the Crypt. EC Comics, 1950 to 1955 (cancelled with #46, February to March 1955).
  2. Qiana Whitted. EC Comics: Race, Shock, and Social Protest. Rutgers University Press, 2019.
  3. Al Feldstein (script), Joe Orlando (art). "Judgment Day!" (Weird Fantasy #18). Weird Fantasy, #18. EC Comics, 1953. Source requires verification
  4. Bradford W. Wright. Comic Book Nation: The Transformation of Youth Culture in America. Johns Hopkins University Press, 2001.
  5. David Hajdu. The Ten-Cent Plague: The Great Comic-Book Scare and How It Changed America. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2008.

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.