ST103 History of Horror Comics
Wertham, the hearings and the Code of 1954
How a psychiatrist, a Senate committee and a frightened industry ended the horror comic.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required The Comics Code of 1954 (text) Comics Magazine Association of America the whole text of the Code
The primary document. Read every clause.
-
Required The Ten-Cent Plague: The Great Comic-Book Scare and How It Changed America David Hajdu the chapters on Wertham, the hearings and the Code
-
As a document of the panic.
-
Optional Censorship and the Comic Book: "Seduction of the Innocent" at 70 Library of Congress the roundtable
A free overview of how historians now see the book.
Introduction
Fredric Wertham's Seduction of the Innocent was published on 19 April 1954[1]. It argued that comic books caused juvenile delinquency and it singled out horror and crime titles, EC's above all. That same month, and again in June, the United States Senate Subcommittee on Juvenile Delinquency held hearings on comics; William Gaines testified and fared badly[2]. By the autumn the publishers had formed the Comics Magazine Association of America and adopted a code of self-censorship, the Comics Code, whose seal appeared on approved covers[3]. EC cancelled Tales from the Crypt with issue #46, cover-dated February to March 1955, rather than gut it[4].
This lesson reads the Code as a document. Not what people say it did, but what it says.
Learning objectives
- Read a regulatory document closely and identify its operative clauses.
- Narrate the events of 1954 accurately.
- Distinguish what the Code forbade from what the panic claimed.
Historical context
Hajdu's account makes the panic a story with many authors: parents' groups, church campaigns, newspaper columnists, city ordinances and comic-book burnings organised by schools, all before Wertham gave the movement a book[2]. Wright sets it in the anxieties of the early Cold War, when the young were a national resource to be protected[5]. The Library of Congress marked the book's seventieth anniversary with a roundtable that is a good, free summary of where the argument now stands[6].
Key concepts
Self-regulation
The Code was not a law. It was an industry agreement enforced through distribution: a comic without the seal would not be carried by most wholesalers. Understanding that mechanism matters, because it explains the loophole of Week 3 (magazines were not comics) and the change of Week 4 (the industry could revise its own rules).
Reading a rule as a fear
Every clause in a code forbids something someone wanted to do. The 1954 Code's rules about the words "horror" and "terror" on covers, about the walking dead, vampires and werewolves, about the depiction of authority, are a negative image of the comics that existed. Read the Code and reconstruct the comic it was written against.
Causation
Did Wertham end the horror comic, or did the market, or did the industry end it itself to save the rest of its business? Historians disagree, and Assignment 2 asks you to. Begin collecting evidence for each explanation now.
Questions to think about while reading
- Which clauses of the Code are about content, and which are about presentation (covers, titles, advertising)?
- Where in the Code is the sentence that forbids the classic monsters? Copy it out.
- What does the Code say about crime being punished? Compare with the EC moral economy.
Things to notice
- The Code's language: "shall", "shall not", "in all cases". It reads like a statute because it wanted to be treated like one.
- What the Code does not mention. Are there fears in Wertham's book that never made it into the rules?
- The seal itself. Find an image of it and think about what it promised a parent.
Reflection questions
- If you had been a publisher in September 1954, what would you have done?
- Does a rule written in fear ever describe the thing it fears accurately?
Homework and tasks
Draft a table for Assignment 1: each clause of the 1954 Code that touches horror, in one column; what it would have forbidden in an EC story or in House of Secrets #92, in the next; a blank third column for the 1971 revision.
Next lesson
Next week: the loophole. Warren's black-and-white magazines, and how horror lived on without the seal.
References
- Fredric Wertham. Seduction of the Innocent. 1954 (published 19 April 1954).
- David Hajdu. The Ten-Cent Plague: The Great Comic-Book Scare and How It Changed America. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2008.
- Comics Magazine Association of America. The Comics Code of 1954 (text). 1954. Link
- Al Feldstein, William Gaines and the EC artists. Tales from the Crypt (EC, 1950 to 1955). Tales from the Crypt. EC Comics, 1950 to 1955 (cancelled with #46, February to March 1955).
- Bradford W. Wright. Comic Book Nation: The Transformation of Youth Culture in America. Johns Hopkins University Press, 2001.
- Library of Congress. Censorship and the Comic Book: "Seduction of the Innocent" at 70. 2024. Link
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.