ST103 History of Horror Comics

The 1971 revision and the monster revival

The rule change that made Swamp Thing and Tomb of Dracula possible, and DC's horror houses.

About 120 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

On 28 January 1971 the Comics Code was revised. Among the changes: vampires, ghouls and werewolves were newly permitted when handled in the classic tradition of Frankenstein, Dracula and other respected literary works[1]. Within fifteen months Marvel had Tomb of Dracula #1 (April 1972) on the stands with the seal on its cover[2], and DC had Swamp Thing.

DC had been edging back toward horror for three years already. EC veteran Joe Orlando took over House of Mystery in 1968, and Cain first hosted the title in #175 (July to August 1968); House of Secrets was revived with Abel as host from #81 (August to September 1969)[3][4]. The revision did not start the revival. It removed the last obstacle to the monsters themselves.

What you are studying

A rule change as a historical cause, and the difference between what a document permits and what publishers then did.

Learning objectives

  • Compare two versions of a regulatory document precisely.
  • Explain the sequence of the DC horror revival with correct dates.
  • Assess how far a rule change explains a creative outcome.

Key concepts

Permission versus cause

The revision permitted monsters. It did not require anyone to publish them. The DC horror revival was already under way and Warren had been publishing monsters for years. Ask how much of Swamp Thing's existence the revision explains, and how much belongs to Orlando, Wein, Wrightson and a market that was already buying House of Secrets.

"The classic tradition"

The revision's phrase is a literary alibi: monsters are allowed if they come with a pedigree. Notice how Swamp Thing's early issues, with their Frankenstein echoes and Victorian settings, could be read as a response to exactly that clause. Was Wein's Gothic literacy a creative choice, a commercial one, or both?

Dates as evidence

January 1971: revision. May 1971: Savage Tales #1, outside the Code. July 1971: House of Secrets #92, inside it. April 1972: Tomb of Dracula #1. November 1972: Swamp Thing #1. Put them on a line and the argument makes itself; the historian's job is to say what the line proves and what it does not.

Questions to think about while reading

  • Which 1954 clauses are deleted in 1971, which are softened, which are new?
  • What does the revision say about drugs, and why does that matter to the period?
  • Does Tomb of Dracula #1 behave as if it were "in the classic tradition"?

Things to notice

  • The seal on Tomb of Dracula #1's cover, next to the word Dracula. Nineteen years earlier that was impossible.
  • Cain and Abel. They are the EC hosts reborn, but softened. How?
  • The tone of the revised Code. Is it still afraid?

Reflection questions

  • If the revision had not happened, would Swamp Thing have appeared anyway, in a Warren-style magazine? What would have been different?
  • What do rule changes usually follow: courage, or sales?

Homework and tasks

Complete the third column of your Assignment 1 table with the 1971 text for each clause, then write a paragraph on the single change that mattered most for Swamp Thing.

Next lesson

Next week: the 1982 revival, Alan Moore, and the comic that stopped carrying the seal.

References

  1. Comics Magazine Association of America. The Comics Code revision of 1971 (text). 28 January 1971. Link
  2. Gerry Conway (writer), Gene Colan (artist). Tomb of Dracula #1. Tomb of Dracula, #1. Marvel Comics, April 1972. Link
  3. Bob Haney, Jack Sparling and Joe Orlando (Cain's first appearance). House of Mystery #175. House of Mystery, #175. DC Comics, July to August 1968.
  4. Various; Abel as host. House of Secrets #81. House of Secrets, #81. DC Comics, August to September 1969. Link

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.