ST103 History of Horror Comics
Warren and the magazine loophole
Creepy, Eerie and the ten years in which horror survived by not being a comic book.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required Creepy #1 Warren Publishing; Archie Goodwin (chief writer and editor, 1964 to 1967) any issue of Creepy from the Goodwin years, in reprint
To see the EC style reborn.
-
Recommended Comic Book Nation: The Transformation of Youth Culture in America Bradford W. Wright the chapter on the Code years
Introduction
The Code applied to comic books. It did not apply to magazines. In 1964 James Warren launched Creepy, a black-and-white horror anthology in magazine format, sold on magazine racks, without the seal; Archie Goodwin was its chief writer and editor from 1964 to 1967, and many of the artists were EC veterans[1]. Eerie followed. For a decade the horror anthology lived in the loophole.
The same loophole is where Man-Thing was born: Savage Tales #1 (May 1971) was a black-and-white magazine, Code-free[2]. Swamp Thing, two months later, was born inside the Code, in a colour comic with the seal[3]. The two swamp monsters are the two sides of the industry in 1971.
Learning objectives
- Explain the magazine loophole and its consequences.
- Compare the Warren style with EC and with 1970s DC horror.
- Understand how format decides audience.
Key concepts
Format and audience
A magazine on a magazine rack is bought by someone older than a comic on a spinner rack. Black and white was cheaper and also read as more serious. Ask what Warren's format allowed its stories to do that a Code comic could not, and what it cost.
Continuity of craft
The EC artists did not vanish in 1955; they went to magazines, to advertising, to Mad. Trace one artist from an EC story you read in Week 1 to a Warren story. The Grand Comics Database will tell you where they went[4].
Two swamp monsters, two industries
Man-Thing in a magazine, Swamp Thing in a comic. Read the two origin stories again with format in mind: length, colour, what each is allowed to show, who it expects to be reading.
Questions to think about while reading
- How long are the stories in your Creepy issue, and how do they compare with EC's?
- Is there a host? How does the host differ from the Crypt-Keeper?
- What is on the cover, and who is the cover for?
Things to notice
- Grey tones. Black-and-white art with washes looks different from colour comics. Describe the difference precisely.
- Advertising. What is sold in the back pages, and to whom?
- Letters pages. Who is writing in?
Reflection questions
- Would Swamp Thing have been a better or worse comic in black and white?
- Is a loophole a kind of freedom, or a kind of exile?
Homework and tasks
Write two hundred words comparing the Man-Thing origin in Savage Tales #1 with House of Secrets #92 on format alone: what each format permits and what it costs.
Next lesson
Next week the rules change: 28 January 1971, and the monsters come back.
References
- Warren Publishing; Archie Goodwin (chief writer and editor, 1964 to 1967). Creepy #1. Creepy, #1. Warren Publishing, 1964.
- Gerry Conway (script), Gray Morrow (art); character conceived by Roy Thomas and Stan Lee. Savage Tales #1 (first appearance of Man-Thing). Savage Tales, #1. Marvel Comics, May 1971.
- Len Wein (writer), Bernie Wrightson (artist). House of Secrets #92. House of Secrets, #92. DC Comics, July 1971.
- Grand Comics Database contributors. Grand Comics Database. Link
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.