ST104 How Comics Create Horror

A full formal reading

Bringing every tool to one page, and testing the tools on an artist from a later run.

About 150 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

You now have the vocabulary: panel, gutter, closure, transition, tier, grid, splash, bleed, line weight, hatching, spotting blacks, palette, balloon, caption, page turn, reveal. This lesson puts it all to work on one page and then asks you to test whether the tools survive a change of artist.

The synthesis is also the shape of Assignment 1. A formal analysis moves from the whole to the parts and back: the page as a picture, then the sequence through it, then the marks and layers, then the effect of the whole on a reader turning to it.

What you are studying

The method of formal analysis, and its limits.

Learning objectives

  • Structure a formal analysis from whole to parts to effect.
  • Choose which tools a page needs and leave out the ones it does not.
  • Recognise when a later artist's choices require new vocabulary.

Key concepts

Order of operations

Start with the page as a picture (layout, blacks, dominant panel). Then the sequence (transitions, timing, the page turn before and after). Then the layers (line, colour, letters). Then the effect, and only then interpretation. Interpretation that arrives before description is guessing.

Selection

Not every tool applies to every page. A regular grid needs less said about layout and more about rhythm. A silent page needs nothing said about lettering except that it is silent. Choosing what to say is part of the analysis.

Testing the tools

Bissette and Totleben draw differently from Wrightson: denser, more painterly, more interested in texture across the whole page. Does the vocabulary still fit? Where you find yourself reaching for a new word, write it down; that is the beginning of your own critical language.

Questions to think about while reading

  • What is the first thing a reader sees on your page? Is it what the artist wanted them to see first?
  • Where does the page's time slow and speed up?
  • What would be lost if this page were printed in black and white?

Things to notice

  • Your own habits. What do you always notice first, and what do you always miss?
  • The Guidebook's chapter on form: what its authors think a formal reading should contain.
  • Chute's method, which reads form and history together. Is that better or just different?

Reflection questions

  • Has this module changed how you read comics for pleasure? For better or worse?
  • Which single tool from the six weeks will you use most in the rest of the degree?

Homework and tasks

Draft Assignment 1: a full formal analysis of your chosen page, in the whole-to-parts-to-effect order, with every claim checkable against the page.

Next lesson

This is the last lesson of ST104. Both assignments are open on the module page. ST105 follows: Nature, Body and Transformation, where the swamp stops being scenery.

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.