ST104 How Comics Create Horror

Staging the reveal

How horror comics control when you see the monster, with the page turn as the medium's jump scare.

About 120 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

Film has the cut and the jump scare. Comics have the page turn. Because a reader sees a whole spread at once, an artist who wants to surprise must hide the surprise on the other side of the page, so that turning it is the reveal. Eisner's chapter on timing treats the sequence of panels as a control on the reader's clock, and the page turn as the largest beat available[1].

This lesson reads two reveals: the last page of House of Secrets #92 and the central reveal of The Saga of the Swamp Thing #21, where a body is opened and a truth with it[2][3]. What is on the left-hand page, what is on the right, and what did the artist make sure you could not see until you turned.

What you are studying

Timing at the level of the page and the spread, and the reveal as the horror comic's central formal device.

Learning objectives

  • Analyse the placement of reveals relative to page turns.
  • Describe how withholding and showing are paced across a story.
  • Compare two artists' handling of the same device.

Key concepts

The spread

Two facing pages are one visual unit. Anything on the right-hand page is visible while you read the left. An artist who wants a shock puts it on the next left-hand page, or hides it in a small panel the eye reaches last. Map both stories as spreads and note where the shocks fall.

Withholding

The monster you have not seen is scarier than the one you have. Count how many panels each story lets you see the creature clearly, and where. Then count how many show a part, a shadow or a reaction instead.

The reaction shot

Comics, like film, can show fear on a face instead of the thing feared. Reaction panels are cheap and effective. Note when each artist uses them and whether they are a substitute for the reveal or a preparation for it.

Questions to think about while reading

  • On which page number does each story's reveal fall, and is that page a left or a right?
  • What is the last panel before each reveal, and how big is it?
  • After the reveal, what does the story do with the next page?

Things to notice

  • Panel size at the reveal. Is it the biggest panel in the story?
  • Viewpoint. Is the reveal seen from a character's eyes or from nowhere?
  • Text. Is there a caption over the reveal, or does the picture stand alone?

Reflection questions

  • Which reveal worked on you, and did it work the second time?
  • Digital reading destroys the page turn. What does a horror comic lose on a phone?

Homework and tasks

Write two hundred and fifty words comparing the two reveals: page placement, panel size, what was withheld before and what follows after.

Next lesson

Next week, synthesis: putting the module's tools together on a page from a later era of your choosing.

References

  1. Will Eisner. Comics and Sequential Art. Poorhouse Press (later W. W. Norton), 1985.
  2. Len Wein (writer), Bernie Wrightson (artist). House of Secrets #92. House of Secrets, #92. DC Comics, July 1971.
  3. Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette (pencils), John Totleben (inks), Tatjana Wood (colours), John Costanza (letters). The Saga of the Swamp Thing #21: "The Anatomy Lesson". The Saga of the Swamp Thing, #21. DC Comics, February 1984.

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.