ST104 How Comics Create Horror
The page as a picture
Layout, tiers, grids and their breaking; Groensteen's idea that a page means all at once.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required Swamp Thing #1: "Dark Genesis" Len Wein (writer), Bernie Wrightson (artist) the whole issue
For its layouts.
-
Recommended The System of Comics Thierry Groensteen, translated by Bart Beaty and Nick Nguyen the introduction and the chapter on the page
Difficult; read for the argument, not every term.
Introduction
Before you read a single panel you see the whole page. Its shape, how many tiers it has, whether it is a regular grid or something broken, whether one panel dominates, where the black is. Thierry Groensteen's System of Comics argues that this is not incidental: a comic means through the relations across the page and across the book, what he calls arthrology, and reading only the sequence misses half of what is there[1].
Wrightson's pages in Swamp Thing #1 are the material. Some are regular grids. Some are not. This lesson asks when and why.
Learning objectives
- Describe a page layout precisely: tiers, panels per tier, dominant panel, direction of reading.
- Explain the effect of regular and irregular grids.
- Apply Groensteen's idea of the page as a network to a specific page.
Key concepts
The grid
A regular grid (two by three, three by three) is a metronome: each panel gets equal time. Breaking it changes tempo. A wide panel slows; a tall thin one accelerates or isolates; a splash stops the clock. Find the first page in #1 where Wrightson breaks his own pattern and note what is happening in the story.
The page as a picture
Groensteen's claim is that the panels on a page relate to each other as a composition, not only as a sequence: shapes rhyme, blacks balance, a figure in the top left answers one in the bottom right[1]. Test it: on one page, describe the relations that are not sequential.
Eisner's framing
Eisner treats the panel border as a stage frame and the page as a set of decisions about what the reader is allowed to see and from where[2]. His examples are from his own work; apply his questions to Wrightson's.
Questions to think about while reading
- How many layouts does #1 use? Group the pages by type.
- Where is the largest panel in the issue, and what is in it?
- Does the layout of the last page echo the first?
Things to notice
- Direction. Does the eye always go left to right, top to bottom? Where does Wrightson steer it otherwise?
- Black. Where the darkest panels sit on the page, and whether they cluster.
- Text weight. Pages heavy with captions look different from pages that are mostly picture. Does the layout compensate?
Reflection questions
- Does seeing the page as a picture make the story more or less frightening?
- Which theorist, McCloud or Groensteen, describes what you actually do when you read? Or do you do both?
Homework and tasks
Choose one page of Swamp Thing #1 and write two hundred and fifty words on its architecture: the grid or its breaking, the dominant panel, the non-sequential relations, and what the design does to the story on that page.
Next lesson
Next week the mark itself: line, brush, black and texture, and how Wrightson's ink makes rot.
References
- Thierry Groensteen, translated by Bart Beaty and Nick Nguyen. The System of Comics. University Press of Mississippi, 2007 (French original 1999).
- Will Eisner. Comics and Sequential Art. Poorhouse Press (later W. W. Norton), 1985.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.