ST104 How Comics Create Horror
The panel and the gutter
What a panel is, what the space between panels does, and why horror lives in the gap.
Reading for this lesson
-
You know it. Now count it.
-
After your own count.
Introduction
A comic is made of pictures in sequence, but the sequence is not on the page. Between any two panels is a gap, the gutter, and the reader supplies what happens there. Scott McCloud calls the act of supplying it closure, and argues that it is the medium's defining operation: the reader is a collaborator who commits the murder the panels only imply[1].
Horror depends on that gap more than any other genre. What you are not shown, you imagine, and what you imagine is worse. This lesson asks you to find the gutters that do the most work in House of Secrets #92 and to say what you put in them.
Learning objectives
- Define panel, gutter and closure and use the terms accurately.
- Classify panel-to-panel transitions using McCloud's categories.
- Identify the transitions in a horror story that carry the fear.
Key concepts
The panel
A panel is a framed moment, though the moment may last a second or a year. Its size, shape and border are decisions. A borderless panel bleeds; a panel that fills the page is a splash. Note what each choice does to time and attention.
Closure and transitions
McCloud sorts transitions into types: moment to moment, action to action, subject to subject, scene to scene, aspect to aspect, and the non-sequitur[1]. Count the transitions in the story and see which types dominate. Then ask which single transition does the most, and whether it is one where a body is lost from view.
The gap as horror
The convention of not showing is old: the Greek stage kept violence offstage; the Gothic novel keeps the monster in the dark. In comics the gutter is the offstage. Find the panel just before and just after the story's central violence and describe what the gutter holds.
Questions to think about while reading
- How many panels does the story have? How many per page? Does the count change at the climax?
- Where does the story use a scene-to-scene transition, and what does it skip?
- Is there a panel that shows less than the one before it? Why?
Things to notice
- Borders. Are they all the same weight? Are any broken?
- The page turn. Which panel is the last on a right-hand page, and what is on the next?
- Silence. Panels with no words at all, and where they fall.
Reflection questions
- Did your line-per-gutter exercise change how you read the story?
- Is closure a kind of complicity? Does horror make you do something you would not do for another genre?
Homework and tasks
Produce a transition map of House of Secrets #92: every gutter numbered and classified by McCloud's types, with one sentence on the three that matter most.
Next lesson
Next week the page itself: layout, tiers, the grid and its breaking.
References
- Scott McCloud. Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art. Kitchen Sink Press (later HarperCollins), 1993.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.