ST105 Nature, Body & Transformation
Bakhtin and the grotesque body
The body that eats, rots, grows and overflows, and why it is comic as well as terrible.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required Rabelais and His World Mikhail Bakhtin, translated by Helene Iswolsky the introduction and the chapter on the grotesque image of the body
Long but rewarding. Read after your first thoughts.
-
Required Swamp Thing #1: "Dark Genesis" Len Wein (writer), Bernie Wrightson (artist) the whole issue
For the creature's body.
-
Recommended Swamp Thing #3: "The Patchwork Man" Len Wein (writer), Bernie Wrightson (artist) the whole issue
For the Patchwork Man beside him.
Introduction
Mikhail Bakhtin's Rabelais and His World, written in the 1930s and 1940s and published in English in 1984, describes a body that classical art tried to hide: the grotesque body, which is never finished, which bulges and sprouts and opens, which is always in the act of becoming something else and always in exchange with the world through its mouth, its bowels, its sex and its death[1]. For Bakhtin this body is the body of carnival, and its mode is laughter. It is also, unmistakably, Swamp Thing's body.
This lesson takes the grotesque as a concept and applies it to a creature who is made of what grows, who has roots for bones and moss for skin, and who is drawn by an artist who understood that rot is a texture.
Learning objectives
- Define the grotesque body in Bakhtin's terms.
- Apply the concept to a comics body with specific visual evidence.
- Consider the relation between the grotesque and laughter, and whether horror can hold both.
Key concepts
The classical and the grotesque
Bakhtin sets two bodies against each other: the classical body, closed, smooth, complete, a statue; and the grotesque body, open, protruding, incomplete, a process[1]. Superheroes are classical bodies. Swamp Thing is the other kind. Notice how Wrightson draws the difference when the two share a panel, as in Swamp Thing #7 with Batman.
Exchange with the world
The grotesque body is not sealed. It takes the world in and gives itself out. A body made of plants photosynthesises, roots, decays and feeds. Ask where in the early issues the creature's body is shown exchanging with its environment, and where it is drawn as if sealed.
Laughter
Bakhtin insists the grotesque is joyful: carnival laughter at the body's excess. Horror is not usually joyful. Ask whether there is laughter anywhere in the Wein and Wrightson issues, and what happens to the grotesque when the laughter is taken away.
Questions to think about while reading
- List every part of the creature's body that Wrightson shows growing, dripping, breaking or rooting.
- Does the creature eat? Sleep? Bleed? What does the story avoid showing?
- Is the Patchwork Man grotesque in Bakhtin's sense, or is he something else?
Things to notice
- Bakhtin's examples are from a sixteenth-century French novel. Note where his terms strain when moved to a 1970s comic.
- The creature's outline. Wrightson often lets it break; the body has no clean edge. Find three panels.
- Faces. The grotesque face in Bakhtin is all mouth and nose. What is Swamp Thing's face made of?
Reflection questions
- Would you call Swamp Thing's body beautiful? Does Bakhtin let you?
- Is there a comedy of Swamp Thing waiting to be written, or is the character too sad for carnival?
Homework and tasks
Write two hundred and fifty words applying Bakhtin's grotesque body to Swamp Thing #1, with at least four panels as evidence and one place where the concept does not fit.
Next lesson
Next week: the abject. Kristeva on rot, corpses and the border between you and what you expel.
References
- Mikhail Bakhtin, translated by Helene Iswolsky. Rabelais and His World. Indiana University Press, 1984 (Russian original 1965).
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.