ST105 Nature, Body & Transformation
Body horror and The Fly
Why a changing body frightens, watched at length in Cronenberg's film and again in Swamp Thing #1.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required The Fly David Cronenberg (director and co-writer); Jeff Goldblum, Geena Davis the whole film
Ninety-six minutes. Watch it once straight through, then the transformation scenes again.
-
Required Swamp Thing #1: "Dark Genesis" Len Wein (writer), Bernie Wrightson (artist) the origin sequence
Compare the two transformations.
Introduction
Body horror is the sub-genre in which the source of fear is the body itself: its change, its opening, its refusal to stay what it was. David Cronenberg's The Fly (1986) is its most complete statement, a film that follows a scientist's fusion with an insect from the first stray hair to the end, and that lets him describe what is happening to him as it happens[1]. Swamp Thing #1 compresses the same event into a few pages: a man goes into the water and something else comes out[2].
The difference in pace is the first thing to think about. Cronenberg's horror is gradual and narrated; Wein and Wrightson's is sudden and mute. Each choice decides what the transformation can mean.
Learning objectives
- Define body horror and identify its conventions.
- Analyse a transformation scene in film and in comics.
- Compare gradual and sudden transformation as narrative strategies.
Key concepts
Body horror
The horror of the body is the horror of not being in charge of what you are. Disease, ageing, pregnancy, mutation: every ordinary bodily change is a small version of the sub-genre's fear. Body horror makes the change visible and fast. Ask what The Fly's transformation is a metaphor for, if it is one, and whether the film wants you to decide.
Gradual and sudden
A gradual transformation lets a character witness and interpret his own change; The Fly's scientist keeps notes and jokes. A sudden one produces a finished monster who must work out afterwards what he is. Swamp Thing's later writers, above all Moore, will turn the sudden origin into a slow discovery. Notice that the seed is already here: the creature in #1 does not know what he is either.
Sympathy with the changing body
Both texts want you to feel for the body that changes. Locate the exact moment in each where sympathy is asked for, and describe the technique: a line of dialogue, a close-up, a panel of the creature's face.
Questions to think about while reading
- In The Fly, what is the first sign of change, and how long before the character notices?
- What does the film do with the scientist's voice as his body goes?
- In Swamp Thing #1, how many panels does the transformation get, and what is shown in them?
Things to notice
- Practical effects. The Fly's transformation is made of latex and paint; that physicality is part of its horror. What is the comics equivalent?
- Witnesses. Who watches each transformation, and what does their face do?
- Naming. When does each text stop calling the character by his human name?
Reflection questions
- Is Swamp Thing body horror? Or is body horror only the first page of his story?
- What would The Fly be if the scientist had liked what he became?
Homework and tasks
Write two hundred and fifty words comparing the two transformations on pace alone: what each medium's speed allows the text to say about the body.
Next lesson
Next week: the grotesque body, and Bakhtin's argument that an open, changing, overflowing body has been laughed at for as long as it has been feared.
References
- David Cronenberg (director and co-writer); Jeff Goldblum, Geena Davis. The Fly. 20th Century Fox / Brooksfilms, 1986.
- Len Wein (writer), Bernie Wrightson (artist). Swamp Thing #1: "Dark Genesis". Swamp Thing (1972 series), #1. DC Comics, October to November 1972. Link
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.