ST202 Love, Sex, Bodies and the Nonhuman
Down Amongst the Dead Men: the descent
Annual #2, the Orpheus story, and how Moore used DC's supernatural characters to draw a cosmology.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required Swamp Thing Annual #2: "Down Amongst the Dead Men" Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette and John Totleben (art) the whole annual
Long; give it an evening.
-
Recommended Deadman Book One Arnold Drake and Jack Miller (writers), Carmine Infantino and Neal Adams (art) the first two stories
Deadman before Moore borrowed him: the origin and the first Neal Adams issue.
-
The original issue, if you can find it; Book One reprints it.
Introduction
Swamp Thing Annual #2 (January 1985), "Down Amongst the Dead Men", is the run's descent into the underworld[1]. Abby's soul is in Hell; the creature swears to follow, and does, guided in turn by Deadman, the Phantom Stranger, the Spectre and Etrigan. It is the Orpheus story, and it is also Moore's first full use of DC's stock of supernatural characters, arranged into a geography of the afterlife that later writers, Gaiman above all, would inherit.
ST302 will read that inheritance. This week reads the annual as a love story told as a journey, and asks what it means that the run's most ambitious issue is about getting a woman back.
Learning objectives
- Analyse a katabasis (descent) narrative and its stages.
- Understand how Moore assembled DC's supernatural characters into a system.
- Read the annual's ending as a statement about love and the nonhuman.
Key concepts
Katabasis
The hero goes down to bring someone back. Orpheus, Dante, and a hundred comics since. The form has stages: the threshold, the guide, the ordeal, the bargain, the return with a condition. Map the annual onto them and note where Moore departs.
Cosmology from continuity
The Phantom Stranger dates from 1952, Deadman from 1967, the Spectre from 1940, Etrigan from 1972. None was created to fit with the others. Deadman, Boston Brand, is a circus acrobat shot dead in mid-act who can possess the living[2]; Neal Adams's issues gave him the look Bissette and Totleben inherit[3]. Read his first two stories and note what Moore keeps: the possession, the unfinished business, the grief of a man who cannot be touched. Moore's annual makes them a set: regions of one afterlife, guides of one journey. Ask what the arrangement says about Heaven, Hell and the space between, and whether it is a theology or a map.
The return
What comes back from Hell, and in what condition? Read the last pages carefully. The annual's answer to "can love recover the dead?" is qualified, and the qualification is the point.
Questions to think about while reading
- What does each guide know that the creature does not?
- How is Hell drawn: architecture, colour, the bodies of the damned?
- What does the creature give up, or risk, to make the journey?
Things to notice
- Scale. Bissette and Totleben draw the afterlife as landscape. Compare with the Green in #23.
- The Spectre's role. He is the DC universe's embodiment of vengeance; what does the annual do with that?
- Captions. Whose voice narrates the descent?
Reflection questions
- Is this the creature's most human act, or his least?
- Does the annual believe in Hell, or use it?
Homework and tasks
Write two hundred and fifty words on the annual as an Orpheus story: which stages it keeps, which it changes, and what the change means for what the creature is.
Next lesson
Next week: Pog and the abandoned house. Two standalone issues about love, loss and the tradition.
References
- Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette and John Totleben (art). Swamp Thing Annual #2: "Down Amongst the Dead Men". Swamp Thing Annual, #2. DC Comics, January 1985.
- Arnold Drake (writer), Carmine Infantino (art). Strange Adventures #205. Strange Adventures, #205. DC Comics, October 1967.
- Arnold Drake and Jack Miller (writers), Carmine Infantino and Neal Adams (art). Deadman Book One. DC Comics.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.