ST202 Love, Sex, Bodies and the Nonhuman

Pog and Abandoned Houses

A homage to Pogo that ends in grief, and the 1971 origin retold inside Moore's mythology.

About 100 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

Between Hell and the love scene, Moore wrote two standalone issues. "Pog" (January 1985) is an homage to Walt Kelly's newspaper strip Pogo: alien animals, refugees from a ruined world, arrive in the swamp speaking in portmanteau words and looking for a home[1]. "Abandoned Houses" reprints the House of Secrets #92 story inside a new frame, retelling the 1971 origin as a dream within the house of Cain and Abel[2].

The pair teach two things. First, that Moore's tenderness is real and unsentimental: "Pog" is gentle and it ends in a way that is not. Second, that the run is aware of its own tradition: #33 takes the first story you read in this degree and folds it into the mythology, so that Wein and Wrightson's Victorian scientist becomes a prior instance of the creature's own type.

What you are studying

Homage as a mode, and a series re-reading its own origin.

Learning objectives

  • Analyse homage and pastiche as critical acts.
  • Read a framing device and what it changes in the framed story.
  • Connect Moore's re-reading of House of Secrets #92 to the swamp-monster type from ST101.

Key concepts

Homage

"Pog" borrows Kelly's characters, his swamp and his wordplay, and puts them to a purpose Kelly's strip never had. Ask what the borrowing lets Moore say that his own characters could not, and why a horror comic wanted a gentle issue here, between #31 and #34.

The frame

#33 frames the 1971 story. Framing changes meaning: a story told as a dream, in a haunted house, by a host, is a different story from one told straight. Describe the frame exactly and say what it does to the Wein and Wrightson pages inside it.

The type, again

ST101 defined the swamp-monster type and set Swamp Thing as one instance. #33 makes the 1971 creature and the 1984 creature two instances inside one fiction: the type becomes a lineage of plant elementals, which #47 will formalise. Note the moment the connection is made.

Questions to think about while reading

  • In "Pog", who are the refugees and what destroyed their world? Is it named?
  • How does Shawn McManus's art differ from Bissette and Totleben's, and why might that suit the issue?
  • In #33, what does the frame add to the last panel of the 1971 story?

Things to notice

  • Portmanteaus. Collect ten and unpack them.
  • Cain and Abel. The DC hosts from ST103, now inside the story rather than presenting it.
  • The reprinted art. Is it recoloured? Relettered? Compare with your ST101 copy.

Reflection questions

  • Is "Pog" a horror story?
  • What does it mean for a series to absorb its own origin as a dream?

Homework and tasks

Write two hundred and fifty words on #33's frame: what it is, what it does to the 1971 story, and what it claims about the creature's place in a lineage.

Next lesson

Next week: "Rite of Spring".

References

  1. Alan Moore (writer), Shawn McManus (art). The Saga of the Swamp Thing #32: "Pog". The Saga of the Swamp Thing, #32. DC Comics, January 1985. Source requires verification
  2. Alan Moore (writer); reprints the House of Secrets #92 story by Len Wein and Bernie Wrightson within a new frame. The Saga of the Swamp Thing #33: "Abandoned Houses". The Saga of the Swamp Thing, #33. DC Comics, 1985. Source requires verification

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.