ST203 American Gothic

Southern Change and Strange Fruit: #41 to #42

A television production on a plantation wakes the dead of slavery. The storyline's most direct political horror, read with Whitted.

About 150 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

"Southern Change" and "Strange Fruit" (October to November 1985) bring a television crew to a Louisiana plantation to film a melodrama about the old South, and the past rises to meet them[1][2]. The second title is the song Billie Holiday made famous, about lynched bodies hanging from trees. Moore is using the zombie, the possession story and the plantation Gothic to write about slavery and its afterlife, and he is an Englishman doing it in an American comic in 1985.

That combination is the subject of this week. Qiana Whitted's book on EC showed horror comics using shock to argue about race in the 1950s[3]. Thirty years on, Moore does it again, with more room and less excuse. The question is whether the story earns the title it borrows.

What you are studying

Horror as historical argument, and the ethics of who tells which story.

Learning objectives

  • Analyse how the story uses horror conventions to represent the history of slavery.
  • Apply Whitted's account of race and shock in horror comics to a 1985 text.
  • Assess the story's position and voice: who speaks, who suffers, who is redeemed.

Key concepts

The past as monster

American Gothic, Botting notes, is a mode in which the nation's history returns as horror[4]. Here the return is literal. Ask what form the dead take, what they want, and whether the story lets them speak or only act.

Shock as argument, again

Whitted's EC preachies used the twist ending to indict the reader[3]. Moore's two-parter has no twist; its indictment is structural. Compare the methods and decide which is more honest.

Who tells it

The story is written by a white Englishman and drawn by white Americans, and its subject is Black suffering. That is a fact about the text, not a verdict on it. Ask how the story handles its own position: whose point of view organises the pages, and what the Black characters are given to do and to say.

Questions to think about while reading

  • What is the television production, and what does the story think of it?
  • How is the plantation drawn? Is it beautiful?
  • What does the creature do in these issues? Is he central or a witness?

Things to notice

  • The song. If you do not know "Strange Fruit", find a recording. The title is doing work.
  • Bodies in trees. The story's central image, and its most dangerous one.
  • The ending. Who is left, and in what state?

Reflection questions

  • Is this story the storyline's best, or its most problematic, or both?
  • What would Whitted say about it? What would you say to Whitted?

Homework and tasks

Write three hundred and fifty words assessing "Strange Fruit" as horror about race: its method, its position, and whether it earns its title, with Whitted as your conversation partner.

Next lesson

Next week: the tuber shared, the bogeyman, and the house of guns.

References

  1. Alan Moore (writer). The Saga of the Swamp Thing #41: "Southern Change". The Saga of the Swamp Thing, #41. DC Comics, October 1985.
  2. Alan Moore (writer). The Saga of the Swamp Thing #42: "Strange Fruit". The Saga of the Swamp Thing, #42. DC Comics, November 1985.
  3. Qiana Whitted. EC Comics: Race, Shock, and Social Protest. Rutgers University Press, 2019.
  4. Fred Botting. Gothic. The New Critical Idiom. Routledge, 2014 (second edition; first edition 1996).

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.