ST203 American Gothic
Windfall, Bogeymen and Ghost Dance: #43 to #45
The tuber as drug, the serial killer, and a house built by a gun fortune and haunted by its dead.
Reading for this lesson
-
The gun house.
-
Re-read beside #45.
Introduction
Three issues, three American fears. "Windfall" (December 1985) gives the creature's tuber to two people and lets it act as a drug: for one, a good trip; for the other, the worst[1]. "Bogeymen" (January 1986) is a serial-killer story[2]. "Ghost Dance" (February 1986) is a haunted house, built by the heirs of a gun fortune and modelled on the Winchester Mystery House, in which the ghosts are everyone the family's guns ever killed[3].
Each is a horror sub-genre with a topical charge. Together they show the storyline's method at its most schematic, and its most pointed.
Learning objectives
- Analyse the topical charge of a horror story without reducing it to a message.
- Read the haunted house convention through Poe and through American history.
- Compare three issues as variations on one method.
Key concepts
The drug story
The tuber that was sacrament in "Rite of Spring" is a substance in "Windfall". What changes is the user. Ask what the issue says about drugs, about the Green, and about whether the creature's body can be misused.
The killer
The serial killer was America's monster of the 1980s. "Bogeymen" gives him a mind and a method. Compare with Arcane: what is the difference between a supernatural villain and a human one, in a comic that has both?
The house of guns
Poe's house of Usher was a family's decay made architecture[4]. Moore's gun house is a nation's, and its ghosts are a count. Read #45 beside Poe and describe what has been kept, what enlarged, and what the count of the dead is doing.
Questions to think about while reading
- In "Windfall", what decides who has the good trip and who the bad? Is it fair?
- How is the killer in "Bogeymen" drawn, and how much of him do you see?
- In "Ghost Dance", how does the house work? What are its rules?
Things to notice
- The creature's role shrinking. In two of these issues he is barely present.
- Interiors again. The house of guns is all corridors.
- Titles. Each borrows: a weather word, a nursery word, a Native American religious movement. What does each borrowing claim?
Reflection questions
- Which of the three is still topical, and which has dated?
- Is a horror comic the right place for an argument about guns?
Homework and tasks
Write three hundred words on "Ghost Dance" as an American House of Usher: what Moore keeps from Poe, what he changes, and what the change says.
Next lesson
Next week: the world. Revelations, the Parliament of Trees, and the Brujeria.
References
- Alan Moore (writer). The Saga of the Swamp Thing #43: "Windfall". The Saga of the Swamp Thing, #43. DC Comics, December 1985.
- Alan Moore (writer). The Saga of the Swamp Thing #44: "Bogeymen". The Saga of the Swamp Thing, #44. DC Comics, January 1986.
- Alan Moore (writer). The Saga of the Swamp Thing #45: "Ghost Dance". The Saga of the Swamp Thing, #45. DC Comics, February 1986.
- Edgar Allan Poe. "The Fall of the House of Usher". Burton's Gentleman's Magazine. Project Gutenberg, September 1839. Link
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.