ST204 The Green and Eco-Horror

All Flesh Is Grass: #61 and the universal Green

A planet of sentient plants, a Green Lantern who is one, and grief as the creature has never seen it.

About 120 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

Exiled from Earth in the run's final year, the creature travels the galaxy, and in "All Flesh Is Grass" (1987) he reaches J586, a planet of sentient plants, where the Green Lantern Medphyll, himself a plant, is mourning his mentor Jothra[1]. The issue is the Green taken off Earth. If it exists on J586 too, it is not Gaia; it is something bigger.

The title is from Isaiah: all flesh is grass, and the grass withers. The issue is about death in a world where death is composting. This lesson reads it as the run's answer to what the Green means beyond one planet, and as a test of whether Moore's ecology has room for grief.

What you are studying

The Green as a universal principle, and mourning in a vegetable world.

Learning objectives

  • Analyse #61 as an extension of the Green beyond Earth.
  • Read grief and death in a world where all life is plant.
  • Apply Alaimo and Morton to a non-terrestrial ecology.

Key concepts

The universal Green

If J586 has its own Green, the concept is cosmic. Ask what that does to the ecological reading: is a cosmic Green still about the Earth, or has Moore turned ecology into theology?

Grief that composts

Medphyll mourns. The issue asks what mourning means when the dead return to the ground and the ground is alive. Compare with the burial in #28. Trans-corporeality, Alaimo's term for bodies flowing into one another[2], is literal here, and it is not a comfort.

Dark ecology

Morton's dark ecology refuses the consolations of "nature" as a beautiful whole and asks for coexistence with what is strange and uncomfortable[3]. J586 is strange and uncomfortable and beautiful. Ask which Morton would say.

Questions to think about while reading

  • How does Medphyll's ring work on a world of plants? What does the science-fiction frame add?
  • What does the creature learn from Jothra's death that Earth had not taught him?
  • What does the title mean by the end?

Things to notice

  • The art of a plant world. What Earth-plant forms are borrowed and what invented.
  • The Green Lantern Corps. A superhero institution inside an ecological fable.
  • Silence, again. Compare with #28 and #47.

Reflection questions

  • Is a cosmic Green more or less hopeful than an earthly one?
  • Has the run's ecology become a religion?

Homework and tasks

Write three hundred words on #61 as the Green's limit case: what the issue claims about the Green's scope, and whether the claim helps or harms the ecological reading.

Next lesson

Next week: ecohorror as a field, and where Swamp Thing sits in it.

References

  1. Alan Moore (writer). Swamp Thing #61: "All Flesh Is Grass". Swamp Thing, #61. DC Comics, June 1987.
  2. Stacy Alaimo. Bodily Natures: Science, Environment, and the Material Self. Indiana University Press, 2010.
  3. Timothy Morton. Dark Ecology: For a Logic of Future Coexistence. Columbia University Press, 2016.

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.