ST204 The Green and Eco-Horror

Ecohorror as a field

Rust and Soles, Tidwell and Soles, and the question of whether Swamp Thing is a monster, a champion, or a warning.

About 150 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

Ecohorror is a young field. Stephen Rust and Carter Soles's special cluster in ISLE in 2014 gave it a name and a working definition: horror in which nature is the source of fear, or in which harm to nature is the horror[1]. Christy Tidwell and Carter Soles's 2021 collection consolidated it[2]. Swamp Thing belongs to it from both directions: the creature is nature made frightening, and the run's villains, from Woodrue to Nukeface, are harm to nature made flesh.

This lesson reads the field's founding texts and asks where the creature sits. A chapter in a university repository asks the question directly, "EcoGothic monster or environmental champion?", and its answer, once you have verified the record, is one to argue with[3].

What you are studying

A critical field's self-definition, and the placing of a text within it.

Learning objectives

  • Explain ecohorror as a field with its founding texts and definitions.
  • Locate Swamp Thing within it, from both directions.
  • Test the monster-or-champion question against the run.

Key concepts

Two directions

Ecohorror runs both ways: nature as threat (the swamp, the plant, the creature) and threat to nature (waste, oxygen, the axe). The run is unusual in doing both with one character. Ask what that doubleness allows and what it costs.

Monster or champion

The question assumes the two are opposites. Cohen's fourth thesis, that the monster dwells at the gates of difference, suggests they need not be[4]. Ask whether Swamp Thing is a champion because he is a monster, and what the run would lose if he were only one.

The field's blind spots

Ecohorror scholarship has been mostly about film. Comics offer something film does not: the page as landscape, the panel as ecosystem. Ask what a comics ecohorror would need to say that the field's founding texts do not.

Questions to think about while reading

  • How do Rust and Soles distinguish ecohorror from horror set in nature?
  • What examples do Tidwell and Soles's contributors use, and does any comic appear?
  • Where does the run fit their categories, and where does it exceed them?

Things to notice

  • The word "Anthropocene" in the 2021 title. What it claims, and whether the run anticipates it.
  • Your own fear. Which issues frightened you for nature, and which frightened you of it?
  • The repository chapter's title. A question. Answer it before you read.

Reflection questions

  • Is ecohorror a genre, a mode, or a reading practice?
  • Does naming a field change what its texts mean?

Homework and tasks

Write three hundred and fifty words placing Swamp Thing in ecohorror: both directions, with issues as evidence, and one thing the field's definition cannot account for.

Next lesson

Last week: the essay. Hope, horror, or both.

References

  1. Stephen A. Rust and Carter Soles. "Ecohorror Special Cluster: Living in Fear, Living in Nature". ISLE: Interdisciplinary Studies in Literature and Environment, vol. 21, #3. 2014.
  2. Christy Tidwell and Carter Soles (editors). Fear and Nature: Ecohorror Studies in the Anthropocene. Pennsylvania State University Press, 2021.
  3. "Swamp Thing: EcoGothic Monster or Environmental Champion?". Link Source requires verification
  4. Jeffrey Jerome Cohen (editor). Monster Theory: Reading Culture. University of Minnesota Press, 1996.

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.