ST204 The Green and Eco-Horror

Deep ecology and Gaia

Naess and Lovelock, read as the intellectual weather in which the Green was written.

About 150 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

Two ideas were in the air when Moore began the run. Arne Naess's 1973 article distinguished a "shallow" ecology, concerned with pollution and resources for human benefit, from a "deep" one that grants non-human life intrinsic value and asks humans to see themselves as one part of a whole[1]. James Lovelock's 1979 book proposed that the Earth's living and non-living systems together regulate the planet's conditions, as if the planet were alive[2]. Neither is cited in the comic. Both are in it.

This lesson reads the two texts and then asks which the Green resembles, and where it departs. It also introduces the criticism deep ecology attracted, which is Woodrue's problem stated by philosophers: if all life has equal value, what is the human claim?

What you are studying

Two foundational ecological ideas and their relation to a comic.

Learning objectives

  • Summarise deep ecology and the Gaia hypothesis accurately.
  • Compare each with the Green as written in #22 to #24 and #47.
  • Understand the misanthropy objection to deep ecology and its presence in the run.

Key concepts

Shallow and deep

Naess's distinction is a distinction about motive: do we protect nature for us or for itself[1]? The Parliament of Trees protects nothing for anyone; it sits. Ask whether the Green is a deep ecology or something with no human term at all.

The living planet

Lovelock's Gaia is a scientific hypothesis about feedback, not a mystical claim, though it was often read as one[2]. The Green is a mystical claim that behaves like feedback: it responds to damage, it produces champions. Say precisely where the analogy holds and where it breaks.

The misanthropy objection

Critics of deep ecology argued it could licence indifference to human suffering. Woodrue is that objection with a body. Ask whether the run answers it (through the creature's choice to protect the animal) or only stages it.

Questions to think about while reading

  • What does Naess mean by "biospherical egalitarianism", and does the Green practise it?
  • What, for Lovelock, would count as evidence that the planet regulates itself?
  • Does the creature, in #24, act as a deep ecologist, a Gaian agent, or a man?

Things to notice

  • Dates. 1973, 1979, 1984. Ideas take about a decade to reach a comic.
  • Language. Naess writes as a philosopher; Lovelock as a scientist; Moore as a poet. What does each register allow?
  • What none of the three mention: horror.

Reflection questions

  • Do you hold a shallow or a deep ecology? Did the run move you?
  • Is the Green a comfort or a threat, on this week's reading?

Homework and tasks

Write three hundred words comparing the Green with either deep ecology or Gaia: the resemblance, the departure, and what the departure is for.

Next lesson

Next week: the Parliament of Trees, read closely.

References

  1. Arne Naess. "The Shallow and the Deep, Long-Range Ecology Movement: A Summary". Inquiry, vol. 16. 1973. pp. 95 to 100.
  2. James Lovelock. Gaia: A New Look at Life on Earth. Oxford University Press, 1979.

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.