ST204 The Green and Eco-Horror
The Green as idea: Woodrue and #22 to #24
Woodrue hears the Green and draws the wrong conclusion; the creature enters it and draws a different one.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required The Saga of the Swamp Thing #22: "Swamped" Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette and John Totleben (art) the whole issue
-
Required The Saga of the Swamp Thing #23: "Another Green World" Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette and John Totleben (art) the whole issue
The Green, from inside.
-
Required The Saga of the Swamp Thing #24: "Roots" Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette and John Totleben (art) the whole issue
-
Gaia, five years before the Green.
Introduction
Jason Woodrue makes contact with the Green in #22 and concludes that animal life is a disease the planet should cure: he kills the people of Lacroix, Louisiana, and plans to raise the atmosphere's oxygen until everything that breathes it burns[1]. The creature, meanwhile, has rooted himself and dreamed for weeks, and in #23 his mind enters the Green for the first time[1]. In #24 he returns and stops Woodrue, and the Justice League, watching from orbit, decides the matter is beyond them[2].
The storyline gives the Green two readers, and they disagree. Woodrue reads it as a command to purge; the creature reads it as a connection that includes the animal. This lesson reads both, and asks what the Green actually is, on the page, before any theory is applied.
Learning objectives
- Describe the Green as Moore first wrote it, from the pages.
- Analyse Woodrue's ecology as a position, not only a villainy.
- Read #23's Green sequence formally.
Key concepts
What the Green is
Collect every statement the issues make about the Green: who can hear it, what it wants, whether it wants anything. You will find fewer than you expect. Moore builds it by experience rather than definition, and the experience is #23's.
Woodrue's ecology
Woodrue's conclusion, that the planet would be better without animals, is a real position pushed to its end. Deep ecology's critics have accused it of exactly this misanthropy. Ask whether the storyline is a caricature of ecological thought or a genuine test of it, and what the creature's answer in #24 amounts to.
Gaia
Lovelock's hypothesis, that the Earth's living systems regulate the planet as if it were one organism[3], was published in 1979. The Green is a comic's version of the same intuition, restricted to plants and given a voice. Ask what the restriction and the voice change.
Questions to think about while reading
- How does Woodrue hear the Green, and what does the art do when he does?
- In #23, what does the Green look like? Is it a place?
- What is the creature's argument against Woodrue in #24? Is it an argument at all?
Things to notice
- Lacroix. A town killed off-panel. Compare with the towns of American Gothic.
- The Justice League. Superheroes as observers of an ecological crisis they cannot address.
- Oxygen. Woodrue's weapon is the air. Note the science, and whether the comic cares if it is right.
Reflection questions
- Is Woodrue wrong, or only extreme?
- What did the Green feel like to you as a reader? Peaceful? Frightening?
Homework and tasks
Write three hundred words defining the Green from #22 to #24 alone, quoting the pages, and ending with what the storyline leaves undefined.
Next lesson
Next week: the theory. Deep ecology and Gaia, tested against the creature.
References
- Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette and John Totleben (art). The Saga of the Swamp Thing #23: "Another Green World". The Saga of the Swamp Thing, #23. DC Comics, April 1984.
- Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette and John Totleben (art). The Saga of the Swamp Thing #24: "Roots". The Saga of the Swamp Thing, #24. DC Comics, May 1984.
- James Lovelock. Gaia: A New Look at Life on Earth. Oxford University Press, 1979.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.