ST204 The Green and Eco-Horror
Hope, horror, or both
The Green as Moore left it, the scholarship as it stands, and the essay.
Reading for this lesson
-
Moore's farewell; read for what the Green has become.
-
Recommended Ecology without Nature: Rethinking Environmental Aesthetics Timothy Morton the introduction
Against the idea of "nature".
-
Optional "Infirm Relatives and Boy Kings: The Green Man Archetype in Alan Moore's The Saga of The Swamp Thing" the chapter, if accessible
Requires verification.
-
Optional "Strange Daddy: Uprooting the Environmentalist Family Romance in Nancy A. Collins' Swamp Thing" the article, if accessible
On the Collins run; useful for the essay's future.
Introduction
Moore's last issue, "Return of the Good Gumbo" (September 1987), brings the creature home[1]. The Green he leaves behind has been an experience (#23), a creed (#47), a universal (#61) and a weapon in the wrong hands (#22 to #24). The scholarship since has read it as the Green Man[2], as ecoGothic, as environmentalism and as something more ambivalent. This last lesson takes stock and sets up the essay: is the Green, as Moore wrote it, an ecological hope, an ecohorror, or both at once?
Morton's argument that the very idea of "nature" as something separate and beautiful is an obstacle to ecological thought[3] is the sharpest tool for the question. The Green is not nature in that sense. It is inside the creature, inside Abby after the tuber, inside Woodrue's madness. It is not a view.
Learning objectives
- Synthesise the Green's development across the run.
- Evaluate the ecocritical readings and locate a gap.
- Plan a research essay that uses a peer-reviewed article critically.
Key concepts
The Green's arc
Experience, creed, universal, weapon. Order the four and ask whether they cohere. Then ask what #64 adds: a homecoming is a statement about where the Green lives.
Ecology without nature
Morton would say the run's achievement is to make ecology a matter of bodies and connections rather than landscapes and views[3]. Test that against the art, which is full of landscapes and views. Maybe the art and the idea disagree; that would be an essay.
The critical gap
Beineke reads the Green Man; the repository chapter reads monster and champion; the MUSE article reads the Collins run's family. None, as far as you have read, reads the Green through dark ecology or ecohorror as a field. That gap is where a first-class essay lives.
Questions to think about while reading
- What does the creature do with the Green in #64, and what does that say?
- Where in the run is the Green frightening, and where hopeful, and are those the same places?
- Which of this module's theorists would the Parliament of Trees agree with?
Things to notice
- Your paragraph from the start. Test it against the lesson.
- The scholarship's dates: 2009, 2010, 2024. The field is still forming. You are writing into it.
- Which sources you have verified and which remain marked. The essay must not cite what you have not seen.
Reflection questions
- Has the module changed how you see a swamp, a tree, a plant on a windowsill?
- Is "hope, horror or both" a real choice, or a false one the essay should refuse?
Homework and tasks
Draft the plan of Assignment 2: your answer, the four texts you will read closely, the theory you will use, the peer-reviewed article you will argue with, and the gap you claim.
Next lesson
This is the last lesson of ST204. Both assignments are open. ST205 follows: Constantine, magic and the occult.
References
- Alan Moore (writer). Swamp Thing #64: "Return of the Good Gumbo". Swamp Thing, #64. DC Comics, September 1987.
- Colin Beineke. "Her Guardiner": Alan Moore's Swamp Thing as the Green Man. ImageTexT: Interdisciplinary Comics Studies, vol. 5, #4. 2010. Link
- Timothy Morton. Ecology without Nature: Rethinking Environmental Aesthetics. Harvard University Press, 2007.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.