ST205 Constantine, Magic and the Occult
The Summoning: magic as practice
The seance of #49, what it shows magic to be, and who pays for it.
Reading for this lesson
-
Recommended The Saga of the Swamp Thing #50: "The End" Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette, John Totleben and Rick Veitch (art) the first six pages
For where the seance leads.
-
Who Zatanna was in 1964: a stage act with a missing father.
-
Optional Zatanna by Paul Dini Paul Dini (writer; Adam Beechen on #15 to #16), Stéphane Roux, Chad Hardin, Rick Mays and others (art) the first four issues
The modern Zatanna: what the character became after Moore.
-
Optional Deadman Book One Arnold Drake and Jack Miller (writers), Carmine Infantino and Neal Adams (art) the first two stories
Deadman, the other borrowed guide, at his origin.
Introduction
"The Summoning" (June 1986) is the run's most detailed picture of magic done: Constantine gathers a circle of DC's occult characters for a seance to support the creature's battle in Hell, and the seance has a price[1]. Magic in Moore's run is never free and rarely clean. The lesson reads the issue as an account of what magic is, in this fiction: a practice with rules, participants, materials and casualties.
It also asks what Moore's magic owes to real occult tradition. The rule of this module is that you may attribute a practice or an idea to a tradition only when you have verified the attribution in a credible source; the history of Western occultism is full of invented lineages, and a degree in horror does not need to add to them.
Learning objectives
- Analyse the seance of #49 as a depiction of magical practice.
- Identify what the issue shows magic to require and to cost.
- Practise verified attribution when discussing occult tradition.
Key concepts
The circle
Constantine's circle is Sargon the Sorcerer; Zatanna and her father Zatara, who insists on chaperoning her; Doctor Occult, who comes on his own initiative after dreaming of the threat; and Steve Dayton, Mento; with Baron Winters tricked into lending his Georgetown house as the base[1]. Zatanna has been a DC magician since Hawkman #4 (November 1964), a stage act whose spells are spoken backwards and who was looking for her missing father[2]; Zatara is older than Superman, from the same June 1938 issue of Action Comics[3]. The seance is a collective act, and Moore uses the shared universe to populate it. Check each character's first appearance on the Grand Comics Database before you write about them, and read Zatanna's origin story to see what Moore keeps: the stage, the backwards words, the father.
The price
Someone always pays for magic in the run. The bill for this seance comes in #50: Sargon catches fire, and Zatara shames him into dying like a sorcerer; then Zatara speaks a spell to burn in his daughter's place, and warns Constantine to keep her safe or be haunted for it[4]. Find how #49 sets that price up and how #50 frames it: as tragedy, as the cost of doing business, as Constantine's fault. The modern Zatanna carries the memory[5].
Attribution
If the seance resembles a real practice, say so only with a source. If you cannot find one, describe the page and stop. This is the difference between criticism and folklore.
Questions to think about while reading
- What materials does the seance use, and what do they do?
- How is the parallel between the seance and the battle in Hell drawn on the page?
- What does Constantine feel at the end of the issue? Does the art show it?
Things to notice
- Cross-cutting. Two scenes, one issue. How the transitions are managed.
- Hands. Magic in comics is often done with hands. Watch them.
- Names. Every magician in the circle has a history; the issue assumes you know it. What happens to a reader who does not?
Reflection questions
- Does the run believe in magic, or in its cost?
- What would this issue look like without the shared universe?
Homework and tasks
Write three hundred words on magic as practice in #49: what it requires, what it costs, and how the page makes the cost visible. Attribute nothing to real tradition without a source.
Next lesson
Next week: "The End" and the answer to the Darkness.
References
- Alan Moore (writer). The Saga of the Swamp Thing #49: "The Summoning". The Saga of the Swamp Thing, #49. DC Comics, June 1986.
- Gardner Fox (writer), Murphy Anderson (art). Hawkman #4. Hawkman, #4. DC Comics, November 1964.
- Fred Guardineer (writer and artist). Action Comics #1 (the Zatara story). Action Comics, #1. DC Comics, June 1938.
- Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette, John Totleben and Rick Veitch (art). The Saga of the Swamp Thing #50: "The End". The Saga of the Swamp Thing, #50. DC Comics, July 1986.
- Paul Dini (writer; Adam Beechen on #15 to #16), Stéphane Roux, Chad Hardin, Rick Mays and others (art). Zatanna by Paul Dini. DC Comics.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.