ST205 Constantine, Magic and the Occult

The answer to the Darkness: #50

The debate with the Darkness, the creature's answer, and the yin and yang: what the run believes about evil.

About 150 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

In "The End" (July 1986) the Darkness, risen from beneath creation, asks what evil is for, and each of the assembled powers answers[1]. Etrigan says it is evil, and is broken. The Spectre offers vengeance, and is broken. The creature says he cannot know: he has seen cruelty fall on the guilty and the innocent alike, and it cannot be understood. Then he remembers the Parliament of Trees, and offers a guess: that evil might be the humus of virtue's decay, the dark loam from which virtue grows strongest. The Darkness and the light meet in a two-page spread of clasped hands, and the image becomes a yin and yang.

It is a horror comic ending in a philosophical position, and the position is not a comfortable one. This lesson reads the debate as a debate, the creature's answer as an ecology turned into a theology, and the final image as a piece of visual argument.

What you are studying

A climax as argument, and a comic's theology.

Learning objectives

  • Reconstruct the debate of #50 accurately.
  • Analyse the creature's answer as a development of the Parliament's ecology.
  • Read the yin and yang spread as visual argument.

Key concepts

The failed answers

Etrigan's and the Spectre's answers fail. Ask why the story needs them to: what each answer assumes about evil, and what the Darkness does with the assumption.

Humus

The creature's answer is compost. Evil as the decay from which virtue grows is the Parliament's ecology (ST204) applied to ethics, and it is the run's most audacious move: a plant's idea of good and evil. Ask whether it is a real answer or a beautiful evasion, and whether the issue knows the difference. Note that the creature says first that he cannot know. The humility is part of the answer.

The spread

Two hands, two pages, one symbol. The yin and yang is borrowed, and the borrowing is an argument: that the comic's cosmology is one of balance rather than victory. Describe the spread exactly and say what it claims that the words do not.

Questions to think about while reading

  • How is the Darkness drawn as it listens? Does it have a face?
  • What does Constantine do during the debate, and what does he lose?
  • What is the last page, after the spread, and what tone does it strike?

Things to notice

  • Three artists on one issue. Which pages belong to whom, and does the debate change hands?
  • The word "evil". How often it is used, and by whom.
  • The Spectre's fate. DC's embodiment of vengeance is defeated by a question.
  • Zatara's death. A father burning in his daughter's place in a Georgetown drawing room while the cosmic battle happens elsewhere: the human cost of the theology, and the scene Zatanna's later writers keep returning to[2].

Reflection questions

  • Do you accept the creature's answer? What would you have said to the Darkness?
  • Is balance a moral position or an abdication?

Homework and tasks

Draft Assignment 1: #49 and #50 as a single work about what magic and evil are, the debate reconstructed, the answer assessed, the spread read.

Next lesson

Next week: the magician. Moore in 1993, Promethea, and the Bumper Book.

References

  1. Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette, John Totleben and Rick Veitch (art). The Saga of the Swamp Thing #50: "The End". The Saga of the Swamp Thing, #50. DC Comics, July 1986.
  2. Paul Dini (writer; Adam Beechen on #15 to #16), Stéphane Roux, Chad Hardin, Rick Mays and others (art). Zatanna by Paul Dini. DC Comics.

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.