ST205 Constantine, Magic and the Occult
What magic is for
Constantine, the seance, the Darkness, the magician: the module's argument and the research essay.
Reading for this lesson
-
Recommended Alan Moore: Comics as Performance, Fiction as Scalpel Annalisa Di Liddo the chapter on performance
-
Recommended Alan Moore and the Gothic Tradition Matthew J. A. Green (editor) any chapter on magic or the occult in Moore
-
Moore on craft, written during the run; is craft a magic?
Introduction
The module has read magic four ways: as a character's trade (Constantine), as a practice with a price (#49), as a cosmology (#50) and as an artist's creed (Moore after 1993). The last lesson asks what it is for. In the run, magic does not defeat the Darkness; understanding does, and the understanding is a plant's. In Moore's later work, magic does not change the world; it changes the mind that perceives it. Both are modest claims wearing spectacular clothes, and the essay asks you to decide whether the modesty is the point.
Di Liddo's reading of Moore's comics as performance[1] and Gray's account of his career as public dissent[2] are the scholarly frames; the Green collection's chapters place the magic within the Gothic[3]. Moore's own 1985 essay on writing comics, written in the middle of the run, is the control: the craft before the creed[4].
Learning objectives
- Synthesise four accounts of magic into a position.
- Engage with scholarly readings of Moore as performer and dissenter.
- Plan a research essay with verified sources only.
Key concepts
Modesty in spectacle
The run's cosmic climax ends in "I cannot know" followed by a guess. Moore's magic ends in "it is art". Ask whether the spectacle is a delivery system for modesty, and what horror has to do with either.
Performance
Di Liddo reads Moore as a performer of comics rather than a mere writer[1]. If the writer is performing, the magician is a role. Ask whether that reduces the magic or explains it.
Craft as the control
The 1985 essay is about panels, pacing and the reader's mind[4]. Its subject is how to change what someone experiences by arranging symbols. Decide whether that is already the theory of magic, eight years early.
Questions to think about while reading
- What does Di Liddo mean by performance, and does #49 fit?
- What does Gray say Moore's dissent is against, and is magic part of it?
- Does the 1985 essay contain the 2024 book?
Things to notice
- Your paragraph. Revise it now.
- Sources still marked as requiring verification. Verify or drop them before the essay.
- Constantine's absence from this lesson. He started the module and has vanished. Is that the point?
Reflection questions
- Has the module made magic more or less credible to you?
- What is the difference between a spell and a comic?
Homework and tasks
Draft the plan of Assignment 2: your position on what magic is for in Moore, the four texts you will read closely, the scholarship you will use, and the occult claims you have verified.
Next lesson
This is the last lesson of ST205. Both assignments are open. ST206 follows: the cosmic year and Moore's departure.
References
- Annalisa Di Liddo. Alan Moore: Comics as Performance, Fiction as Scalpel. University Press of Mississippi, 2009.
- Maggie Gray. Alan Moore, Out from the Underground: Cartooning, Performance, and Dissent. Palgrave Macmillan, 2017.
- Matthew J. A. Green (editor). Alan Moore and the Gothic Tradition. Manchester University Press, 2013.
- Alan Moore. Alan Moore's Writing for Comics. Avatar Press, 2003 (essay first serialised in Fantasy Advertiser #92 to #95, August 1985 to February 1986).
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.