ST205 Constantine, Magic and the Occult
Moore the magician
The 1993 declaration, Promethea, and The Moon and Serpent Bumper Book of Magic: what the writer of Swamp Thing came to think magic was.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required The Moon and Serpent Bumper Book of Magic Alan Moore and Steve Moore, illustrated by Kevin O'Neill, Melinda Gebbie, John Coulthart, Steve Parkhouse, Rick Veitch and Ben Wickey the opening chapters
A long book; read the introduction and the first section.
-
Optional Interview with Alan Moore on magic Jay Babcock (interviewer) the whole interview, once verified
Requires verification; confirm the URL first.
-
Recommended Alan Moore, Out from the Underground: Cartooning, Performance, and Dissent Maggie Gray the chapter on performance
For Moore's magic as public act.
Introduction
On his fortieth birthday, in November 1993, Alan Moore declared himself a magician. He has said since that he worships Glycon, a Roman snake god exposed as a puppet in antiquity, and that he chose the god because it was a known fraud. Between 1999 and 2005 he wrote Promethea, thirty-two issues with J. H. Williams III in which a superhero comic became a guided tour of the Kabbalah, the tarot and the history of magic[1]. In October 2024, after decades of work, The Moon and Serpent Bumper Book of Magic, written with the late Steve Moore, was published as a children's annual for adults[2].
None of this was in Swamp Thing, which was written by a man who had not yet made the declaration. But #50's answer to the Darkness, the seance of #49, the Parliament and the Green all read differently once you know where the writer went. This lesson reads Moore's magic as a development of the run's ideas, and asks what magic came to mean for him: not power over the world, on his account, but a way of understanding imagination, language and art as the real thing.
Learning objectives
- Describe Moore's turn to magic accurately, with verified facts only.
- Analyse Promethea #1 and the Bumper Book as statements of a theory of magic.
- Read Swamp Thing #49 and #50 back through that theory.
Key concepts
Magic as art
Moore's recurring claim, in interviews and in the Bumper Book, is that magic and art are the same activity: the manipulation of symbols to change consciousness. Find the claim in the Bumper Book's own words, cite the page, and test it against #50. If magic is art, the creature's answer to the Darkness is a spell.
The chosen fraud
Glycon was a puppet. Moore knew it and chose it. Ask what it means to worship a known fiction, and whether it is the same thing the run does when it builds a theology out of a comic's continuity.
Promethea's method
Promethea teaches while it entertains, and by its middle issues it barely entertains. Compare with #49, which entertains while it teaches. Ask which is the better comic and which the better magic, and whether those are different questions.
Questions to think about while reading
- What is Promethea, in #1? Who becomes her, and how?
- What does the Bumper Book say magic is, in its first definition?
- Where in Swamp Thing does Moore's later theory first show?
Things to notice
- Format. Promethea is a superhero comic; the Bumper Book is an annual. Moore's magic arrives in popular forms. Why?
- Steve Moore, Alan's collaborator and no relation, who died in 2014. The book is also a memorial.
- Illustrators. Kevin O'Neill, Melinda Gebbie, John Coulthart, Steve Parkhouse, Rick Veitch. Veitch was there for #50.
Reflection questions
- Does knowing the writer's later beliefs change how you read the run? Should it?
- Is "magic is art" a claim you can accept, and what would it cost to?
Homework and tasks
Write three hundred and fifty words reading #50 through the Bumper Book's account of magic, citing both by page, and ending with whether the reading illuminates or distorts the issue.
Next lesson
Last week: what magic is for, and the essay.
References
- Alan Moore (writer), J. H. Williams III and Mick Gray (art). Promethea #1. Promethea, #1. America's Best Comics, 1999.
- Alan Moore and Steve Moore, illustrated by Kevin O'Neill, Melinda Gebbie, John Coulthart, Steve Parkhouse, Rick Veitch and Ben Wickey. The Moon and Serpent Bumper Book of Magic. Top Shelf Productions and Knockabout Comics, 15 October 2024.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.