ST301 After Moore: Forty Years of Swamp Thing
Collins and the family: #110 to #139
Nancy A. Collins makes the creature a father, and a peer-reviewed article reads what that meant.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required Swamp Thing by Nancy A. Collins Omnibus Nancy A. Collins (writer), Scot Eaton, Kim DeMulder and others (art) #110 to #115 and one later arc of your choice
-
Required "Strange Daddy: Uprooting the Environmentalist Family Romance in Nancy A. Collins' Swamp Thing" the whole article, once verified
Requires verification; read the MUSE record first.
Introduction
Doug Wheeler wrote the series from #88 to #109; Nancy A. Collins, a horror novelist, took over at #110 and wrote thirty issues and two annuals, 1991 to 1993[1]. Her subject was the family: Abby, the creature, and their daughter Tefé, conceived by Moore's run through Constantine's body and now a small child with elemental power and no restraint. Collins brought in Lady Jane, another plant spirit, to help raise her; she ran the creature for governor of Louisiana; she gave the swamp a mad priest and a dream pirate. Issue #129 carried the first Vertigo logo, the imprint that launched in 1993 on ground Moore's run had cleared.
A peer-reviewed article reads the Collins run through queer ecology as a critique of what Noel Sturgeon called the "environmentalist family romance": the belief, common in popular environmental stories, that the nuclear family is the unit that will save the planet[2]. On this reading the creature's anxious fatherhood is the run's argument, and the argument is against the family as ecological hope. This lesson reads the run and the article together, and uses the article as a model of how to write about a post-Moore run.
Learning objectives
- Analyse the Collins run's turn to family and domesticity.
- Engage with a peer-reviewed reading of it, and assess the reading.
- Use that article as a model for writing about post-Moore comics.
Key concepts
Fatherhood as horror
Tefé kills a kitten that scratched her. The run's horror moves from the swamp into the nursery. Ask what it means for the character who could not be human to have a child who is more powerful and less restrained than he is.
The family romance
Sturgeon's phrase names a pattern: the family as the answer to environmental crisis. The article argues that Collins exposes the pattern by making the creature's need for a normal family the problem[2]. Test the argument against the issues: is the run critiquing the family, or just failing to make it work?
The model
The article is what a scholarly reading of a post-Moore run looks like: a theoretical frame, a specific run, an argument that the run knows something the reader did not. Note its structure. You will write one.
Questions to think about while reading
- How does Collins write Abby? Is she the same woman Moore left?
- What does Lady Jane add, and what does her presence say about the family?
- What is the governor storyline for?
Things to notice
- The Vertigo logo on #129. The moment the character became "mature readers" officially.
- Collins's prose background. The captions, the dialogue, the horror novelist's rhythms.
- The art. Scot Eaton and Kim DeMulder are not Bissette and Totleben. What changes when the swamp is drawn plainly.
Reflection questions
- Is a domestic Swamp Thing still a horror comic?
- Does the article convince you? What would you add?
Homework and tasks
Write three hundred and fifty words assessing the "environmentalist family romance" reading against two Collins issues, citing both the article (once verified) and the pages.
Next lesson
Next week: Morrison and Millar. The end of the world.
References
- Nancy A. Collins (writer), Scot Eaton, Kim DeMulder and others (art). Swamp Thing by Nancy A. Collins Omnibus. DC Comics.
- "Strange Daddy: Uprooting the Environmentalist Family Romance in Nancy A. Collins' Swamp Thing". Link Source requires verification
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.