ST302 The Wider DC Horror Line: From Cain and Abel to Vertigo
Sandman and the inheritance
How Gaiman took the cosmology of Annual #2 and #49 to #50 and built a different mythology on it.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required The Sandman #1: "Sleep of the Just" Neil Gaiman (writer), Sam Kieth and Mike Dringenberg (art) the whole issue
-
Required The Sandman #2: "Imperfect Hosts" Neil Gaiman (writer), Sam Kieth and Mike Dringenberg (art) the whole issue
-
Recommended Swamp Thing Annual #2: "Down Amongst the Dead Men" Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette and John Totleben (art) the whole annual
For comparison.
-
Optional The Books of Magic #1 to #4 Neil Gaiman (writer), John Bolton, Scott Hampton, Charles Vess and Paul Johnson (art) issue #1
Constantine as tour guide.
Introduction
Moore's Annual #2 and #49 to #50 drew a map of DC's supernatural world: Hell, the hosts, the magicians, the Darkness. Gaiman's Sandman took the map and put a new figure at its centre: Dream, one of seven Endless, older than gods. The first two issues show the inheritance directly. #1 is a Gothic captivity story that ends in the DC universe; #2 takes Dream to the House of Mystery, where Cain and Abel host him[1][2]. Two years later The Books of Magic sent a boy on a tour of the same world with Constantine as one of his guides[3].
This lesson reads Sandman's first two issues beside Annual #2 and asks what Gaiman kept, what he replaced and why his mythology, not Moore's, became the line's.
Learning objectives
- Analyse Sandman #1 and #2 as inheritors of Moore's cosmology.
- Compare the two writers' methods of using DC's supernatural stock.
- Assess why Gaiman's version became the line's identity.
Key concepts
Same map, new centre
Moore's cosmology had no centre; the creature was a visitor. Gaiman's has Dream. Ask what putting a protagonist at the centre of the map does to it, and whether the map survives.
Horror to myth
Sandman begins as horror and becomes something else. Find the page in #1 or #2 where the shift starts, and ask whether it is a departure from Moore or a development of #50's move from horror to philosophy.
Why Sandman won
Vertigo's identity was Sandman's. Ask why: the character, the covers, the length, the trade paperbacks, the audience. Then ask what the line would have been if Swamp Thing had remained its centre.
Questions to think about while reading
- Who are the DC characters in Sandman #1, and how are they treated?
- What does Dream want from Cain and Abel in #2, and what does the scene say about the hosts?
- What does Gaiman's Hell owe to Moore's, when you reach it?
Things to notice
- Captions. Gaiman's narrative voice against Moore's.
- Kieth's art. He left after five issues; why?
- The Endless. A new pantheon, invented, beside the borrowed one.
Reflection questions
- Is Sandman a Swamp Thing comic?
- Whose cosmology do you prefer, and why?
Homework and tasks
Write three hundred words on Sandman #2 as an inheritance of Moore's cosmology: what is kept, what is centred, and what the centring changes.
Next lesson
Next week: January 1993. Vertigo.
References
- Neil Gaiman (writer), Sam Kieth and Mike Dringenberg (art). The Sandman #1: "Sleep of the Just". The Sandman, #1. DC Comics, January 1989 (on sale 29 November 1988).
- Neil Gaiman (writer), Sam Kieth and Mike Dringenberg (art). The Sandman #2: "Imperfect Hosts". The Sandman, #2. DC Comics, February 1989.
- Neil Gaiman (writer), John Bolton, Scott Hampton, Charles Vess and Paul Johnson (art). The Books of Magic #1 to #4. The Books of Magic, #1 to 4. DC Comics, late 1990 to early 1991.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.