ST302 The Wider DC Horror Line: From Cain and Abel to Vertigo
1988: the British arrive
Five first issues in fourteen months, each starting from something Moore had touched.
Reading for this lesson
-
Re-read from ST205.
-
Required The Sandman #1: "Sleep of the Just" Neil Gaiman (writer), Sam Kieth and Mike Dringenberg (art) the whole issue
-
Recommended Doom Patrol #19: "Crawling from the Wreckage" Grant Morrison (writer), Richard Case (art) the whole issue
Introduction
Between January 1988 and February 1989, DC published five first issues by British writers, all edited or shepherded by Karen Berger, who had edited Moore's Swamp Thing. Hellblazer #1 (January 1988) gave Constantine his own book[1]. Animal Man #1 (September 1988) began Grant Morrison's twenty-six issues, which end with the writer walking into the comic[2]. Black Orchid #1 (December 1988) was Neil Gaiman and Dave McKean remaking a forgotten heroine as a plant-human hybrid, with Swamp Thing in it[3]. The Sandman #1 (cover date January 1989, on sale 29 November 1988) began the series that would define the line[4]. Doom Patrol #19 (February 1989) was Morrison again, remaking a superhero team as surrealism[5].
Each starts from Moore: a character he created, an ecology he invented, a method he demonstrated. This lesson reads the five first issues together and asks what each takes from the run and what each does that the run did not.
Learning objectives
- Narrate the 1988 to 1989 sequence accurately.
- Analyse each first issue for its debt to Moore and its departure.
- Assess Karen Berger's editorial role from the evidence.
Key concepts
Debt
Constantine is Moore's. Black Orchid's Green is Moore's. Animal Man's premise (a minor superhero taken seriously) is Moore's method with the creature. Sandman's cosmology of DC horror characters is Annual #2's. Doom Patrol's strangeness is Moore's licence. List the debts precisely, with pages.
Departure
Gaiman's Sandman is not a horror comic for long; Morrison's Animal Man becomes a comic about comics; Delano's Constantine is political in a way Moore's was not. Note where each goes that Moore did not, and ask whether the departures are the real inheritance.
The editor
Berger edited Swamp Thing and then these. Her role is usually described as bringing British writers to DC. Ask what the evidence of the five first issues supports: a taste, a method, a market, or all three.
Questions to think about while reading
- What is Black Orchid's relationship to the Green, and to Swamp Thing, in her first issue?
- How does Sandman #1 use DC's existing characters, and which?
- What is the horror in Animal Man #1, and is it horror?
Things to notice
- McKean's painted art. The look of Vertigo before Vertigo.
- Cover design across the five. Dave McKean's Sandman covers as a brand.
- Mature readers labels. Which issues carry one.
Reflection questions
- Is this a movement, or five people?
- Which first issue is the best comic, and which the most important?
Homework and tasks
Draft Assignment 1: one of the five first issues (Black Orchid #1 or Sandman #2 recommended) as a reading of Moore's Swamp Thing.
Next lesson
Next week: Sandman and the inheritance of the cosmology.
References
- Jamie Delano (writer), John Ridgway (art). Hellblazer #1: "Hunger". Hellblazer, #1. DC Comics, January 1988.
- Grant Morrison (writer), Chas Truog (art). Animal Man #1. Animal Man, #1. DC Comics, September 1988.
- Neil Gaiman (writer), Dave McKean (art). Black Orchid #1 to #3. Black Orchid, #1 to 3. DC Comics, December 1988 to February 1989.
- Neil Gaiman (writer), Sam Kieth and Mike Dringenberg (art). The Sandman #1: "Sleep of the Just". The Sandman, #1. DC Comics, January 1989 (on sale 29 November 1988).
- Grant Morrison (writer), Richard Case (art). Doom Patrol #19: "Crawling from the Wreckage". Doom Patrol, #19. DC Comics, February 1989.
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.