ST302 The Wider DC Horror Line: From Cain and Abel to Vertigo

The supernatural stock

The Phantom Stranger, Deadman, Etrigan, the Spectre and Zatanna: where they came from and what Moore made of them.

About 150 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

The four guides of Annual #2 came from four decades and four kinds of comic. The Phantom Stranger first appeared in his own short-lived title in 1952, by John Broome and Carmine Infantino[1]. Deadman, a murdered acrobat who possesses the living, began in Strange Adventures #205 (October 1967), by Arnold Drake and Infantino[2]. Etrigan the Demon, bound to the knight Jason Blood, was Jack Kirby's, in The Demon #1 (September 1972)[3]. The Spectre, the ghost of a murdered detective who became God's vengeance, dates from 1940. And Zatanna, who is not in the annual but sits in Constantine's circle in #49 with her father Zatara, dates from Hawkman #4 (November 1964), created by Gardner Fox and Murphy Anderson[4]; Zatara himself is older than Superman, from the same June 1938 issue of Action Comics[5].

None was designed for the others. Moore used them as a set[6]. This lesson reads the originals, so that you can see what he changed, and asks what it means to inherit characters rather than invent them.

What you are studying

Inheritance as a creative method.

Learning objectives

  • Identify the four characters' origins accurately.
  • Compare each original with Moore's use.
  • Analyse the shared universe as a resource and a constraint.

Key concepts

Four registers

A 1950s mystery, a 1960s adventure, a 1970s Kirby epic, a 1940s ghost. Each character carries his format's tone. Note what Moore does with the tones: unifies them, plays them against each other, or ignores them.

Kirby's Demon

Etrigan is the one of the four with a great creator's signature on him. Read Kirby's #1 for its energy and its rhyme-free demon (the rhyming came later; find out when, and from whom). Ask what Moore's rhyming Etrigan owes to Kirby and what it invents.

The magician's daughter

Zatanna is the stock's only stage performer: a magician whose act is real, whose spells are words said backwards, and whose first story is a search for her father[4]. Ask what Moore does with a character built on a conjuror's joke, and why the run's most affecting death in #50 is her father's. Deadman's first year, reprinted in one book[7], is the comparison: a character built on a tragedy.

The resource

A shared universe is a library. Moore borrowed from it more freely than any writer before him, and the borrowing made a cosmology. Ask what the library gave him that invention could not, and what it cost.

Questions to think about while reading

  • What is the Phantom Stranger in 1952? Is he supernatural at all?
  • How does Deadman's possession work in 1967, and what does Moore do with it in Hell?
  • What is Etrigan's relationship to Jason Blood in Kirby, and in Moore?
  • What does Zatanna do in Hawkman #4, and what does the circle of #49 need her for?

Things to notice

  • Infantino's line on two of the four. A house style across fifteen years.
  • The Spectre's scale. A character who can be the size of a city.
  • Which of the four gets the most pages in Annual #2, and why.

Reflection questions

  • Is a borrowed character ever the borrower's?
  • Which of the four would you write?

Homework and tasks

Write three hundred words on one of the four: original against Moore, what was kept, what changed, and what the change was for.

Next lesson

Next week: 1988. The British writers arrive.

References

  1. John Broome (writer), Carmine Infantino (art). The Phantom Stranger #1. The Phantom Stranger, #1. DC Comics, August to September 1952.
  2. Arnold Drake (writer), Carmine Infantino (art). Strange Adventures #205. Strange Adventures, #205. DC Comics, October 1967.
  3. Jack Kirby (writer and artist). The Demon #1. The Demon, #1. DC Comics, September 1972.
  4. Gardner Fox (writer), Murphy Anderson (art). Hawkman #4. Hawkman, #4. DC Comics, November 1964.
  5. Fred Guardineer (writer and artist). Action Comics #1 (the Zatara story). Action Comics, #1. DC Comics, June 1938.
  6. Alan Moore (writer), Stephen Bissette and John Totleben (art). Swamp Thing Annual #2: "Down Amongst the Dead Men". Swamp Thing Annual, #2. DC Comics, January 1985.
  7. Arnold Drake and Jack Miller (writers), Carmine Infantino and Neal Adams (art). Deadman Book One. DC Comics.

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.