ST306 Dissertation

Revising the dissertation

Structural revision, the introduction and conclusion written last, and the objection chapter tested.

About 180 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

The introduction and conclusion are written last, because only then do you know what the dissertation argues[1]. Revision begins with the three argument chapters read as a stranger would: does each advance the claim, does the evidence carry each step, is the strongest objection met and not merely mentioned? Then the introduction is written to promise exactly what the chapters deliver, and the conclusion to say what has changed.

This workshop gives the procedure: structural revision, then chapter by chapter, then paragraph by paragraph, then the checks. Swetnam's presentation chapter covers the formal apparatus, the contents page, the abstract, the reference list[2].

What you are studying

The revision of a long argument.

Learning objectives

  • Revise structurally before locally.
  • Write an introduction and conclusion that match the chapters.
  • Test the objection chapter against the strongest version of the objection.

Key concepts

Structure first

Read the argument sentences again. Do the chapters, as drafted, still make that argument? Where a chapter has drifted, decide whether the plan or the chapter was right, and change the other.

The objection

Find the strongest reader who would disagree with you and write their case as well as they would. Then answer it. If you cannot, the dissertation's claim needs qualifying, which is not failure; it is research.

Introduction and conclusion

The introduction states the question, the claim, the method and the architecture, in about 1,000 words, and promises nothing the chapters do not deliver. The conclusion restates the claim as now established, says what it changes in the field, and names the limits and the next question.

Questions to think about while reading

  • What does Booth say to look for in a draft's first and last paragraphs?
  • Which chapter drifted, and which way?
  • What is the strongest objection, and who would make it?

Things to notice

  • The abstract. Two hundred words that say question, method, claim and finding. Write it last of all.
  • The contents page. If the chapter titles do not tell the argument, retitle them.
  • Length. 10,000 words excludes the reference list; check the platform's count.

Reflection questions

  • Is the claim you are concluding with the one you proposed? What changed it?
  • What would you cut if you had to lose a thousand words?

Homework and tasks

Complete the structural revision, write the introduction and conclusion, and produce the full revised draft.

Next lesson

Workshop 6: final checks, the reference list, the reflective statement.

References

  1. Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald. The Craft of Research. University of Chicago Press, 2016 (fourth edition).
  2. Derek Swetnam. Writing Your Dissertation: How to Plan, Prepare and Present Successful Work. How To Books, 2001 (third edition).

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.