ST102 Gothic Monsters
Frankenstein: the made body
Shelley's creature, the maker who runs, and the pattern every made monster since has followed.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus (1831 text) Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley the whole novel, or at minimum the chapters in which the creature tells his own story
The creature's narrative is the heart of the book and of this lesson.
-
Optional Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus (1818 text) Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley the same chapters
To compare Shelley's revisions.
-
After your first thoughts.
Introduction
Mary Shelley began Frankenstein in 1816, published it anonymously in 1818, and revised it for the 1831 edition that most readers now know[1]. A student assembles a body from parts, gives it life, and abandons it. The creature, never named, teaches himself to speak and read, is rejected by everyone who sees him, and turns on his maker.
Everything in ST101 descends from this. Arcane's Un-Men are assembled. The Patchwork Man is stitched. Alec Holland is a scientist whose work produces a body he did not intend. Even the shape of Swamp Thing's grief, the longing to be accepted as a man, is the creature's longing. This lesson reads the source.
Learning objectives
- Analyse a nested narrative and account for its effect on sympathy.
- Describe how a monstrous body is written, sentence by sentence.
- Identify the made-body convention and trace it forward to comics.
Historical context
Shelley wrote the first draft at eighteen, in a summer of ghost stories with Byron and Percy Shelley on Lake Geneva; the 1831 introduction tells the story of that summer and of the waking dream that gave her the image of the student kneeling beside the thing he had made[1]. Botting places the novel at the turn where the Gothic stops relying on ghosts and castles and starts drawing its horror from science and the body[2]. The laboratory replaces the crypt. That turn is the one Swamp Thing lives on the far side of.
Key concepts
The made body
A body assembled rather than born carries a set of questions: who owns it, who is responsible for it, whether it has a self. Shelley's creature is made of parts chosen for beauty and is hideous in the sum, which is the novel's first cruelty and its most important idea: the made thing exceeds its maker's intention. Keep this beside Swamp Thing #1, where a formula meant to make deserts bloom makes something else entirely.
The maker who runs
Victor flees the moment the creature opens its eyes. Nearly every made-monster story since keeps that moment: creation followed by abandonment. Ask what the story would be if Victor stayed. Then ask who, in Swamp Thing's world, is the maker who ran.
Nested narration
The creature's story is told to Victor, retold by Victor to Walton, and written down by Walton for his sister. Each layer is a chance to distort. Notice when the frame reminds you it is there, and whether you trust the creature's account more or less for being reported.
Questions to think about while reading
- How does the creature describe his own body, and how does that differ from how Victor describes it?
- What does the creature learn language from, and what does that choice of texts tell you about what Shelley wants him to be?
- Where is the reader asked to feel horror, and where pity? Are those ever the same sentence?
Things to notice
- Shelley almost never describes the creature's appearance in detail. Find the passages where she does, and notice how short they are.
- Weather and landscape: the Alps, the Arctic, the storm. The setting is doing the work of a mood.
- The creature's eloquence. He speaks better than anyone else in the book. Why?
Reflection questions
- Is the creature a monster, a victim, or a hero? You answered this about Swamp Thing in ST101. Is the answer the same here?
- What has comics kept of this story, and what has it thrown away?
Homework and tasks
Choose one passage of no more than a page in which the creature's body is described, by Victor or by himself. Write two hundred words on the sentences: which words carry the horror, which the pity, and how the point of view decides.
Next lesson
Next week the made body becomes the divided one: Stevenson's Dr Jekyll and the man who lives inside him.
References
- Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley. Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus (1831 text). Project Gutenberg (from the 1831 edition), 1831 (first edition 1818). Link
- Fred Botting. Gothic. The New Critical Idiom. Routledge, 2014 (second edition; first edition 1996).
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.