ST102 Gothic Monsters

Jekyll and Hyde: the double

Stevenson's novella and the monster who is also the man.

About 120 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

Stevenson's Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde (1886) is a short novel about a respectable doctor who finds a way to separate the worse part of himself and give it a body of its own[1]. The word "Jekyll and Hyde" has passed into the language, which means most readers know the twist before they open the book. The novella was not written that way: it is structured as a mystery, and the final chapter, Jekyll's own confession, is the reveal.

Read it knowing the secret, and the book becomes a study in how a self is divided and how a body carries that division. Then set it beside Swamp Thing and Arcane, or beside Swamp Thing and Alec Holland, and the point of this week is plain.

What you are studying

A novella in ten chapters, most of them told from the point of view of the lawyer Utterson, with the last two given over to documents: Lanyon's narrative and Jekyll's full statement of the case.

Learning objectives

  • Analyse the double as a Gothic convention and what it externalises.
  • Attend to how witnesses describe a body they cannot quite describe.
  • Compare the Jekyll and Hyde structure with the Swamp Thing and Alec Holland relationship.

Key concepts

The double

The double, or doppelganger, is a figure who shares a self with the protagonist. Botting notes how the nineteenth century used it to stage anxieties about identity, respectability and the hidden life of the city[2]. Stevenson's innovation is to make the double a matter of chemistry: Hyde is produced by a drug, in a laboratory, like a made body. The novella belongs to both of Week 1's conventions at once.

The indescribable body

Nearly every witness in the book says Hyde is deformed and none can say how. The horror is in the failure of description. Compare Wrightson, who has to draw the creature on every page and cannot use that trick, and ask what the comic does instead.

The mystery structure

Because the book withholds the truth until the end, its first reader experiences Hyde as a separate person. Knowing the secret, you experience him as a symptom. Try to recover the first reading, and notice what the second gains.

Questions to think about while reading

  • Count the words used for Hyde's appearance. What do they have in common?
  • What does Jekyll say he wanted from the experiment? Do you believe him?
  • How does London work in the book: the doors, the fog, the back streets?

Things to notice

  • The door. The novella begins with a door, and Hyde has his own. Track every threshold.
  • Handwriting. Whose hand is whose, and why does it matter to the plot?
  • The size of Hyde's body, and what happens to it over the course of the book.

Reflection questions

  • Is Alec Holland Swamp Thing's Jekyll, or his Hyde? Does the answer change between Wein and later writers?
  • What would this story be if Hyde were sympathetic?

Homework and tasks

Write a paragraph comparing the Jekyll and Hyde relationship with one pairing from ST101 (Swamp Thing and Arcane, or Swamp Thing and Alec Holland). What is shared, what is reversed?

Next lesson

Next week the monster comes from outside: Dracula, and the fear of what crosses the border.

References

  1. Robert Louis Stevenson. Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde. Project Gutenberg, 1886. Link
  2. Fred Botting. Gothic. The New Critical Idiom. Routledge, 2014 (second edition; first edition 1996).

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.