ST102 Gothic Monsters

Monster theory: Cohen, Kristeva, Halberstam

The tools of the trade, met after you have formed your own view.

About 150 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

You have now read five monsters on your own terms and written down what you thought before anyone told you what to think. This week you meet the critics. The order matters. Theory read first becomes a template; theory read after becomes a set of questions you can already half answer.

Four writers. Jeffrey Jerome Cohen's "Monster Culture (Seven Theses)" (1996) is the essay every course on monsters starts from[1]. Julia Kristeva's Powers of Horror (1980, English 1982) gives us the abject[2]. Jack Halberstam's Skin Shows (1995) argues that the Gothic monster's body is a machine for producing meaning about class, race, gender and sex[3]. Noel Carroll's The Philosophy of Horror (1990) asks the simplest question, what is horror and why do we want it, and answers it with unusual clarity[4].

What you are studying

Four theoretical accounts of the monster, and the skill of using theory as a lens rather than a verdict.

Learning objectives

  • Summarise each theorist's central claim in your own words.
  • Apply a theoretical claim to a primary text with specific evidence.
  • Notice where a theory fails to fit, and treat the misfit as a finding.

Key concepts

Cohen's seven theses

Cohen argues, across seven short theses, that the monster's body is a cultural body, that the monster always escapes, that it refuses easy categorisation, that it polices the boundaries of the possible and that our fear of it is a form of desire[1]. Each thesis is a question you can put to a text. Which thesis best explains the creature in Frankenstein? Which explains the colour? Which, when applied to Swamp Thing, produces something you had not noticed?

The abject

Kristeva's abject is what the self expels in order to remain a self: bodily waste, the corpse, whatever blurs the border between inside and outside[2]. Horror at the abject is horror at the collapse of that border. A man whose body is made of rotting vegetation, who cannot tell where he ends and the swamp begins, is an abject figure by definition. The concept is difficult in Kristeva's own prose. It is simple in application.

The monster as technology

Halberstam's claim is that the Gothic monster is a device for turning social anxiety into a body: the nineteenth-century monster's skin condenses fears about foreigners, women, the poor and the sexually deviant into one figure that can be hunted[3]. Ask what Swamp Thing's skin condenses in 1971, and what it condenses in 1984.

Art-horror

Carroll's definition: horror is the genre whose monsters are both threatening and impure, and the emotion it produces is a compound of fear and disgust, held in place by curiosity about the monster's nature[4]. It is precise enough to disagree with. Try disagreeing.

Questions to think about while reading

  • For each theorist, what is the one sentence you would use to explain their idea to a friend?
  • Which of your five monsters fits each theory best? Which fits worst?
  • Where do the four theorists disagree with each other?

Things to notice

  • Cohen's examples. He moves fast across cultures and centuries. Note which examples persuade you and which feel stretched.
  • Kristeva's tone. The prose enacts what it describes. That is either a strength or a problem; decide which.
  • Halberstam's historical method. The argument is tied to a period. What happens when you move it to the 1970s?

Reflection questions

  • Did the theory change your reading of any of the five texts? Which, and how?
  • Which theory will you use in Assignment 2, and which will you deliberately leave out?

Homework and tasks

Write a Green Book entry for each theorist with the claim in your own words, one supporting example from a module text, and one text the theory does not fit. Then draft the opening paragraph of Assignment 2.

Next lesson

This is the last lesson of ST102. Both assignments are open on the module page. ST103, History of Horror Comics, follows: how the comics that made Swamp Thing were nearly outlawed in 1954, and what brought them back.

References

  1. Jeffrey Jerome Cohen. "Monster Culture (Seven Theses)". Monster Theory: Reading Culture, ed. Jeffrey Jerome Cohen. University of Minnesota Press, 1996. Link
  2. Julia Kristeva, translated by Leon S. Roudiez. Powers of Horror: An Essay on Abjection. Columbia University Press, 1982 (French original 1980).
  3. Jack Halberstam (published as Judith Halberstam). Skin Shows: Gothic Horror and the Technology of Monsters. Duke University Press, 1995.
  4. Noel Carroll. The Philosophy of Horror, or Paradoxes of the Heart. Routledge, 1990.

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.