ST102 Gothic Monsters

The Colour Out of Space: cosmic and ecological horror

Lovecraft's story of a farm blighted by something from a meteorite, read as the first great ecohorror.

About 100 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

Lovecraft's "The Colour Out of Space" appeared in Amazing Stories in September 1927 and was his own favourite among his stories[1]. A meteorite falls on a New England farm. Something in it, a colour no one can name, gets into the well, the crops, the animals and the family, and the land becomes what the locals call the blasted heath.

You met cosmic horror in ST101, in the tunnel under issue #8. This is its finest short form. And it is something else as well: a story in which the horror is environmental, a contamination of ground and water that spreads outward from a point. Year Two's module on the Green and eco-horror begins from this story. Read it as both.

What you are studying

A story told by a surveyor who hears it from an old man who remembers. Its horror has no face. The question the week asks is whether horror needs a monster, and if not, what replaces one.

Learning objectives

  • Distinguish cosmic horror from the Gothic on their assumptions about the universe.
  • Analyse horror without a monstrous body, and what carries the fear instead.
  • Recognise ecological horror and its structures: contamination, spread, the poisoned home.

Key concepts

Indifference

The Gothic monster wants something: revenge, blood, a body, a name. Lovecraft's colour wants nothing anyone can recognise. The horror is that the universe contains things for which we are not the point. Ask whether Swamp Thing, a man turned into a plant by an accident, is a Gothic or a cosmic figure, and whether the answer depends on the writer.

Horror without a monster

Carroll defines horror by its monsters, which must be threatening and impure, and argues that our disgust and our curiosity are the twin engines of the genre[2]. The colour is threatening and impure but hardly a creature. Test Carroll's definition against it. If the colour is a monster, what is its body?

Contamination

The story's shape is a spread: from meteorite to well, from well to plants, from plants to animals and people. Contamination narratives run through modern horror, from the vampire to the virus to the chemical spill, and they are the natural form of ecological fear. Map the spread in the story and note what resists it.

Questions to think about while reading

  • Who tells the story, and how many removes is the reader from the events?
  • How does Lovecraft describe the colour, given that it cannot be described?
  • What happens to the vegetation, in what order, and what is the last thing to go?

Things to notice

  • The scientists. What they can and cannot measure, and how the story uses their failure.
  • The reservoir. The story ends with the land about to be flooded. What does that do to the horror?
  • The narrator's tone: distant, reasonable, then not.

Reflection questions

  • Compare the blasted heath with the swamp. One is dead and one is teeming. Are they opposites, or two versions of one fear?
  • Is this a story about the environment, or does calling it that impose a modern reading?

Homework and tasks

Write two hundred words arguing for or against the claim that "The Colour Out of Space" has a monster. Use Carroll's definition and at least three specific details from the story.

Next lesson

Next week is theory: Cohen's seven theses, Kristeva's abject, Halberstam's technology of monsters, and what each lets you say about the swamp.

References

  1. H. P. Lovecraft. "The Colour Out of Space". Amazing Stories. September 1927. Link
  2. Noel Carroll. The Philosophy of Horror, or Paradoxes of the Heart. Routledge, 1990.

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.