ST102 Gothic Monsters
The Fall of the House of Usher: the house as body
Poe's tale of a family, a building and a tarn rotting together, and the Gothic landscape it left to the swamp.
Reading for this lesson
-
Short. Read it twice, the second time aloud.
-
Poe is where the tradition crosses the Atlantic.
Introduction
Poe's "The Fall of the House of Usher" was published in Burton's Gentleman's Magazine in September 1839[1]. A narrator visits an old friend, Roderick Usher, in a decaying mansion beside a black tarn; Usher's sister Madeline is dying; the house, the family and the landscape decline together, and the story ends with the building splitting and sinking into the water.
No creature rises from Poe's tarn. But the swamp in every Swamp Thing comic is Poe's tarn: a body of dark water that reflects a ruined structure and receives what falls into it. This lesson reads the story as the source of the Gothic landscape, where the setting is not the background to the horror but its body.
Learning objectives
- Analyse setting as an active element rather than a backdrop.
- Describe how prose produces atmosphere through rhythm, repetition and image.
- Identify the American Gothic and what it changed in the European tradition.
Historical context
Botting describes the American Gothic as the tradition's transplantation into a country without castles, where the wilderness, the frontier and the family house take over the work the ruined abbey once did[2]. Poe's house is a European ruin set down in an unnamed landscape. Alan Moore's Year Two storyline is called American Gothic for a reason; this story is one of the reasons.
Key concepts
Setting as body
Poe's narrator sees the house's windows as eyes, and the fissure in its wall is the family's fault line. When setting is described as a body, the story is telling you where to look for the monster. Ask what the swamp is a body of in Swamp Thing, and whether Wrightson draws it as one.
Atmosphere, technically
Atmosphere is made. Poe's first paragraph is a single long sentence of arrivals and negatives. Count the adjectives. Note the repeated sounds. Watch what the narrator says he cannot explain, and how often. Naming these devices is the difference between saying a story is atmospheric and showing how.
Decline
Nothing in the story gets better. The house, the family line, Roderick's nerves, Madeline's body, the weather. Decline is the plot. This is the Gothic's answer to the Enlightenment's confidence in progress, and it is the emotional key of every swamp story: things sink.
Questions to think about while reading
- What does the narrator see in the tarn before he sees the house? Why that order?
- How is Madeline described, and how much of the story is she actually present in?
- What does Roderick believe about the house, and does the story agree with him?
Things to notice
- The reflection. Poe gives you the house upside down first.
- The storm at the end, and what it lights up.
- The story Roderick and the narrator read aloud, and how its sounds leak into the house.
Reflection questions
- Is there a monster in this story? If so, what is it?
- Find a Wrightson swamp panel from ST101 and set it beside Poe's first paragraph. What does each do that the other cannot?
Homework and tasks
Write two hundred words on Poe's opening paragraph: sentence by sentence, how it builds its mood. Then one sentence on what Wrightson would need to draw to achieve the same effect.
Next lesson
Next week the ground itself goes wrong: Lovecraft's "The Colour Out of Space".
References
- Edgar Allan Poe. "The Fall of the House of Usher". Burton's Gentleman's Magazine. Project Gutenberg, September 1839. Link
- Fred Botting. Gothic. The New Critical Idiom. Routledge, 2014 (second edition; first edition 1996).
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.