ST106 Foundations of Horror Research

Building an argument

Graff and Birkenstein's moves, the thesis statement, and the difference between an opinion and a case.

About 120 minutes. Free to read. You only need an account to keep notes and submit assignments.

Reading for this lesson

Introduction

Academic writing is a conversation. You summarise what others have said, fairly, and then you respond: agreeing, disagreeing, or both, with reasons. Graff and Birkenstein's "They Say / I Say" reduces this to a set of moves with templates, which sounds mechanical and is in fact the quickest cure for writing that only announces opinions[1]. Booth's Part III describes the same thing at a higher level: a claim, reasons, evidence, and the acknowledgement of what could be said against you[2].

This lesson practises the moves on Year One material and produces the skeleton of an argument you could write.

What you are studying

Argument as structure and as conversation.

Learning objectives

  • Summarise a position fairly before responding to it.
  • Write a thesis statement that makes a claim someone could dispute.
  • Anticipate and answer objections.

Key concepts

They say

Start from what others have said: a critic, a common view, your own earlier reading. Summarise it well enough that its holder would nod. Then say what you think. The move is simple and most student writing skips it.

The disputable claim

A thesis you cannot imagine anyone disagreeing with is not a thesis. "Wrightson's art is atmospheric" is not disputable. "Wrightson's use of solid black does more to distinguish the creature from humans than his line does" is. Write claims someone could argue with, and then argue.

Naysayers

Booth and Graff both insist on the objection: state the strongest case against you and answer it. It is not weakness. It is the sign that you have thought.

Questions to think about while reading

  • Which of Graff's templates feel artificial, and which do you already use without noticing?
  • What does Booth mean by a warrant?
  • Look at the marker's feedback on a Year One assignment. Which of these moves was it asking for?

Things to notice

  • Verbs of reporting. "Argues", "claims", "shows", "assumes": each says something about how you rate the source.
  • Transitions. The words that turn summary into response.
  • Your own tics. Every writer has a move they overuse.

Reflection questions

  • Is arguing with a critic disrespectful? What is the respectful way to disagree?
  • Which of your Year One essays would be most improved by adding a naysayer?

Homework and tasks

Write the skeleton of an argument on your chosen question: a they-say paragraph, a thesis sentence, three reasons with the evidence you would use, and the strongest objection with your answer.

Next lesson

Last week: drafting, revising and the proposal that will start Year Two.

References

  1. Gerald Graff and Cathy Birkenstein. "They Say / I Say": The Moves That Matter in Academic Writing. W. W. Norton, various editions (first 2006).
  2. Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald. The Craft of Research. University of Chicago Press, 2016 (fourth edition).

Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.