ST106 Foundations of Horror Research
Drafting, revising and the proposal
The working habits of a finished piece, and how to write the research proposal that opens Year Two.
Reading for this lesson
-
Required The Craft of Research Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald Part IV, on drafting and revising
-
Recommended The Undergraduate Research Handbook Gina Wisker the chapters on planning a project and writing a proposal
Introduction
A first draft is thinking on paper. A finished piece is what is left after you have found out what you think and cut everything that was only finding out. Booth's last part is about that process: drafting fast, revising for the reader, checking that every paragraph earns its place[1]. Wisker's handbook adds the form this module ends on: the research proposal, a short document that states a question, why it matters, how you will answer it and with what[2].
Your Year One is nearly done. The proposal you write this week is the first piece of Year Two.
Learning objectives
- Draft to a plan and revise against a reader's needs.
- Manage a word limit as a design constraint rather than a wall.
- Write a research proposal with question, rationale, method, sources and plan.
Key concepts
Drafting fast, revising slow
Get the argument down without editing. Then revise in passes: structure (does each paragraph do one job), evidence (is every claim supported), sentences (does each say one thing), references (is every borrowed word marked). Booth's advice is to revise for a reader who is intelligent, busy and not on your side[1].
The word limit
A limit is not a wall to bump into; it is the size of the room. Plan the room: how many words for the setup, for each section, for the objection, for the conclusion. Cut from the setup first. Cut adjectives second. Cut the paragraph you are proudest of if it does not serve the claim.
The proposal
Question. Why it matters (the problem). What you will read (primary sources) and what you will read about it (secondary). How you will proceed (close reading, comparison, theory applied, history). What you expect to find, and what would prove you wrong. A page and a half. Wisker's chapters give the standard headings[2].
Questions to think about while reading
- What does Booth say to do with the introduction, and when?
- How does Wisker distinguish aims from objectives?
- Which of your Year One drafts was revised least, and did it show?
Things to notice
- Your revision habits. Do you revise as you draft (slow) or after (faster)?
- The conclusion. Most conclusions repeat. A good one adds.
- Reading aloud. It finds sentences that look right and sound wrong.
Reflection questions
- What have you learned about how you write this year?
- What question do you want to spend Year Two answering?
Homework and tasks
Write the research proposal for Assignment 2. Then revise it in the four passes. Then read it aloud.
Next lesson
This is the last lesson of Year One. When both ST106 assignments are marked and reflected on, Year Two opens with ST201 and "The Anatomy Lesson".
References
- Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb, Joseph M. Williams, Joseph Bizup and William T. FitzGerald. The Craft of Research. University of Chicago Press, 2016 (fourth edition).
- Gina Wisker. The Undergraduate Research Handbook. Palgrave Macmillan, 2018 (second edition).
Want to tick off the reading, keep notes and do the homework? Sign in or join. Reading stays free either way.